Plant Science Bulletin
The Plant Science Bulletin (Print:
ISSN 0032-0919, Electronic: ISSN 1537-9752) is an informal communication
published four times a year, with information on upcoming meetings,
courses, field trips, news of colleagues, new books, and professional
opportunities. It provides a means of advertising items or materials
wanted. It also serves as a forum for circulating BSA committee
reports, for distributing innovative teaching approaches and methods,
and for discussing issues of concern to Society members such as
environmental policy and educational funding.
LAST ISSUE - SPRING,
2008 | SEARCH ALL
ISSUES | ANNOUNCEMENTS
| CAREER OPPORTUNITIES
SUMMER 2008
Table of Contents
News from the Society:
BSA Science Education News and Notes
Editor’s Choice
News from the Sections:
Emanual D. Rudolph Award - Historical Section
Announcements:
In Memoriam
» Jerry McClure (1933-2006)
» James Edward Canright (1920-2008)
Personalia
» Peter Raven Elected to National Geographic Board of Trustees
» Peter Raven wins BBVA Foundation Award for Conservation Biology
Other
» Charles
Darwin's Work with Plants Will Be Brought to Life at The New York
Botanical Garden
» Priming Scientists For Successful Media Interviews
» Three High Horticultural Honors For The Missouri Botanical Garden
» BOOKS REVIEWED
» BOOKS RECEIVED FOR REVEIW
News from the Society
BSA Science Education News and Notes
BSA Science Education News and Notes is a quarterly update about the BSA’s education efforts and the broader education scene. We invite you to submit news items or ideas for future features.
Contact: Claire Hemingway, BSA Education Director, at chemingway@botany.org or Marshall Sundberg, PSB Editor, at psb@botany.org.
PlantingScience — BSA-led student research and science mentoring program
What a remarkable year for PlantingScience — Funding, national recognition, and a doubling in participation!
Hearty thanks to the many BSA scientists who gave your time to coach 368 student research teams through the process of scientific discovery. Your efforts helped to take plant investigations to 1,223 students in 48 classrooms. To date, PlantingScience has reached 2,486 students from 25 states across the nation.
Over 120 scientists are now volunteering as mentors: http://www.plantingscience.org/index.php?module=pagesetter&tid=5&filter=sipscientist:eq:1&tpl=scientists
We invite you to join, or share the opportunity with your colleagues or graduate students. Graduate students and post-doctoral fellows have a special invitation:
Call for 2008-2009 Master Plant Science Team members
Who? Graduate students and post-doctoral fellows.
What? A team of 20 compensated mentors who commit to mentoring 3-4 student research teams via the web and participate in training conversations.
When? Fall 2008 & spring 2009 sessions. Each session lasts ~2-4 weeks.
Where? Online at http://www.plantingscience.org/
Why? To inspire appreciation for plant science in young learners and enrich your professional life.
Benefits are described on the application form available at http://www.botany.org/outreach/MPST_appl08.pdf
Keep in touch with BSA-led education initiatives over the summer by visiting:
PlantingScience http://www.plantingscience.org/
Plant IT Careers, Cases and Collaborations http://www.myplantit.org/
Botany without Borders and Science for Everyone
If you’re looking for education, outreach, and training (EOT) activities at Botany 2008, you’ll find a rich array of workshops, sessions, social events, and special presentations throughout the week. Just a few are highlighted below.
Sunday: 14 free educational and scientific workshops
Monday: PlantingScience Mixer / All-society conversation: EOT that would you like to see at annual meetings
Tuesday: Past-President’s Symposium: Understanding the Crisis in Science Literacy / Women in Science Luncheon
Wednesday: Carl Wieman, Nobel Prize Winner in Physics: Science Education in the 21st Century: Using the tools of science to teach science.
Be sure to visit the education and outreach booth in the Exhibit Hall to:
· Get your PlantingScience T-shirt.
- Try out new features on the PlantingScience website and give us your feedback.
· Listen to podcasts that students make during the July Plant IT program.
- Make a podcast of your own!
· Pick up information and hints on preparing NSF Broader Impacts statements.
Spotlight on BSA Member Contributions to Science Education
Engaging in outreach is nothing new to Melanie DeVore, Georgia Power Endowed Professor in Environmental Science at Georgia College and State University. She writes a newspaper column on environmental issues for the Milledgeville Union Recorder, leads a Study Abroad program in the Bahamas in which student projects are presented at an annual Natural History of the Bahamas Symposium and coordinates a public lecture series, among other activities beyond her active research and publication on paleobotany. Melanie also recently became involved in Georgia College’s Early College Program, which seeks to empower high school students for academic success. Melanie and a high school teacher in the GC Early College Program will partner over the coming years to blend high school and college experiences for underrepresented students. Next year they will begin to integrate PlantingScience mentored inquiry experiences into the program. We are thrilled to have the opportunity to partner with them and support their efforts.
http://info.gcsu.edu/tip/archives/2005/EarlyCollegeprograminitia.html
EOT integral to the iPlant Collaborative
The iPlant Collaborative has been established to catalyze discussions to identify Grand Challenge questions in plant biology that require computational approaches. It serves the entire community of plant science disciplines and has a strong education, outreach, and training component. Susan Singer, chair of the EOT Advisory Committee, moderated the EOT panel discussion at the April Kick-Off Conference held at Cold Spring Harbor. Archived web casts from the Conference and information about EOT opportunities are available at: http://www.iplantcollaborative.org/home.
Editor’s Choice
Crossgrove, Kirsten and Kristen L. Curran. 2008.
Using clickers in nonmajors- and majors-level
biology courses: Student opinion, learning, and
long-term retention of course material. CBE-Life
Sciences Education 7:146-154. http:// www.lifescied.org/cgi/reprint/7/1/146
-Not surprisingly, students were positive about
using clickers in both classes, but the unexpected
results are that student learning and student
retention varied significantly. In general, positive
results were more pronounced in the non-majors
introductory class as opposed to the genetics class
for majors.
Matlack, Glenn R. and Ryan W. McEwan. 2008.
Forest in my neighborhood: An exercise using
aerial photos to engage students in forest ecology
and land use history. The American Biology Teacher 70 (3):13-17.
News from the Sections
Emanual D. Rudolph Award - Historical Section
In 2006 the Historical Section of the Botanical Society
of America established the Emanuel D. Rudolph
Award for the best student paper on a historical
subject in botany to be awarded at the annual
meeting (PSB 52(4): 127). Please encourage your
undergraduate and graduate students to consider
presenting a paper, poster or symposium on a
historical subject in botany to be eligible for this
honor.
In Memoriam
Jerry McClure (1933-2006)
Jerry Weldon McClure, 72, professor emeritus of botany at Miami University,
Oxford Ohio, died Tuesday, April 25, 2006 in Oxford, Ohio. He joined the Miami
University faculty in 1964, attaining full professorship in 1973 and retired
in 2001.
Chair of the Physiological Section, Botanical Society of America 1969-72, editorial
board 72-74 and long term supportive member of the Botanical Society, Jerry
will be missed by the members for his informative conversations on phytochemicals.
McClure was President (also treasurer) of the Phytochemical Society of America.
Jerry was born May 3, 1933 in Floydada, Texas and took pride in having gone
from a depression-era cotton farm and one-room school to becoming an internationally
recognized scientist. At Wayland Baptist College he was offered a music scholarship
in voice, however, he transferred to Texas Tech University, where he earned
a degree in agronomy in 1954. Jerry served in the U.S. Air Force in 1955 to
1959 then he returned to Texas Tech , where he received an M.S. in agriculture.
In 1964, Jerry received his Ph.D. in botany from the University of Texas, Austin.
Throughout his career, he received numerous National Science Foundation and
U. S. Department of Agriculture grants to fund his research. He received the
Alexander von Humboldt Foundation Senior U. S. Scientist Award from the West
German government, in 1974-75, and simultaneously received a Fulbright Foundation
Honorary Research Fellowship award. He was a visiting professor at Ruhr-Universitat,
Bochum, Germany, giving more than 30 invited lectures in the U.K., Belgium,
Netherlands, Poland, USSR and East Germany. In 1982 he was named Distinguished
Visiting Scientist, Texas Tech University; in 1983, he received the Heinrich-Hertz
research award in Dusseldorf, West Germany, and the Gordon Research Conferences
organizing award. In 1987, he was an invited visiting scholar, University of
Nairobi, Kenya, and at the same time, worked with the Richard Leakey group and
National Museums of Kenya. Before returning to Miami University in the fall
of 1987, he presented invited lectures in Africa in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia; Asmara,
Eritrea; and in Peoples Republic of China in Nanking and Guilin.
His public service included being a member of the Council for International
Exchange of Scholars, Life Sciences; screening committee for Fulbright Awards;
screening committee of the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowships Foundation, He
and his wife, Frances were Danforth Faculty Associates; presidents of the McGuffey
Laboratory School PTO and Community Service Program for Foreign Students (COSEP).
His grasp of the scientific literature related to secondary natural products
in plants was remarkable particularly as it related to plant phenolics. Not
only could he cite virtually all recent publications in natural products, Jerry
often provided personal anecdotes about the authors.
As a teacher he encouraged industriousness, initiative, and originality from
his generations of students who remember him as a mentor, advocate, and friend.
James Edward Canright (1920 - 2008)
James Edward Canright passed away on April 9,
2008 at the Hospice of the Valley, Tempe, Arizona.
At 88 years of age, Jim suffered from several ailments
that eventually became too much for him to manage.
Many AASP members, and other professionals will
remember Jim as a direct, no-nonsense person,
who spoke his thoughts clearly and with conviction.
He was, it seemed, a part of the palynological scene
forever. I can still recall my early days in palynology,
hearing of Jim’s impact on our science.
Jim Canright was born in Delaware, Ohio on March
1, 1920. He earned an A.B. degree from Miami
University of Ohio in 1942. Working with I.W. Bailey,
Jim attended Harvard University and completed his
MA (1947) and Ph.D. (1949) in biology. Jim’s work
on evolution of the stamen in primitive angiosperms
is still reproduced today in botany textbooks. He
served as Lieutenant in the US Coast Guard Reserve
in 1942-1946 in the Southwest Pacific area. Jim
married Margaret Barnthouse in 1943, and together
they raised four children, James Douglass,
Lawrence, Susan and Eloise.
From 1949 through most of 1964 Jim served as Instructor and Professor of Botany at Indiana
University, Bloomington, Indiana. It was here at IU
that Jim began the collection of Paleozoic plant
fossils, primarily from the mid-west USA, but also
from several parts of the world. His collections of
this material have formed the basis for several
Masters theses and Doctoral dissertations. I
became familiar with the Canright paleobotanical
collections when they were eventually transferred to
the Florida Museum of Natural History, Gainesville,
where in 1996 through 2002, I was Collection
Manager for Paleobotany and began a detailed
cataloguing and database entry of the Canright
collection. These collections include both a core
assemblage of representative fossil plants that
were originally acquired primarily for teaching, as
well as several subcollections, including fossil coal
samples, fossil and extant pollen samples, and an
extant wood and other plant anatomical structure
collection. Some of this work was published in the
well-illustrated “Fossil Plants of Indiana” published
by the Indiana Department of Conservation,
Geological Survey, in 1959.
In 1964 Jim and his lovely wife Peggy moved to
Tempe, Arizona, where Jim assumed the position
of Professor and Chairman of Botany and
Microbiology at the Arizona State University. He
served in this capacity from 1964 through 1972,
eventually settling comfortably into the role as
Professor of Botany until his retirement in 1985.
ASU awarded Jim the position of Emeritus Professor
upon his retirement, a position he respected and
enjoyed.
In 1971, Jim was an invited Visiting Professor of
Botany at the National Taiwan University in Taipei,
Taiwan. Additionally Jim was recognized by his
colleagues through his association in many
professional organizations. He joined AASP in
1968, and held the office of President for the 1979-
1980 term, member of the 1973 Nominating
Committee, and Chairman of the 11th annual
meeting in Phoenix, AZ. He served as President of
the International Federation of Palynological
Societies (IFPS) from 1992-1996. Jim was Editor of
Palynos, the Newsletter for the IFPS, from 1977
(from its conception) through 1992. Jim Canright
holds the distinction of being the only person to
attend all nine of the IPCs, up to the 10th IPC in China.
Perhaps a little known bit of trivia concerns the
emblem/logo currently used for the IFPS. The
stylized Acacia pollen grain with the letters IFPS
was developed by Jim and designed by his son
James Douglass in 1984 (see: Palynos vol. 7, no.
2, pgs. 1-2).
Travel played an important part on Jim’s life, and it
seems, looking at his Curriculum Vitae, that he
managed to live in six different countries and travel
to at least 45 countries. Part of this travel was
through the courtesy of Uncle Sam, as Jim served
as Communications Officer with the US 7th Fleet
(1943-1945) in the Southwest Pacific arena. While
in Malaysia he learned the basics of the Malayan
language. He lectured in Nepal and India.
Jim was also recognized by his peers through
awards and presentations. Jim was a Fellow of the
Indiana Academy of Science and the American
Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS).
He served on the Governing Board for the American
Institute of Biological Sciences (AIBS), and received
the Outstanding Paleobotanist Award from the
Botanical Society of America. In 1960 he received a
John Simon Guggenheim Fellowship. Jim’s career
has been profiled in American Men and Women in
Science, and Who’s Who in America.
Professor Canright served as Chair or Principal
Advisor for many students working toward their
graduate degrees, both at Indiana University and
Arizona State University. Several of his students will
be immediately recognized by AASP readers, and include Robert Romans, Joseph M. Wood, Gottfried
Guennel, Donald Engelhardt, William Dickison,
Robert A. Stewart, Jerome Ward, John D. Shane,
Michael Zavada and Michael Farabee.
I really only truly got to know and appreciate Jim
Canright through our association involving the IFPS.
When I was Secretary-Treasurer of the IFPS, I
worked closely with Jim on several matters. We
attended all the scheduled meetings and a few ad
hoc meetings together in order to firmly establish
the “process and procedures” necessary to build a
strong international association. The record shows
that thanks to Jim’s commitment as Editor and
eventually President of the IFPS, that organization
today stands on a firm, well thought out constitution
and working bylaws. We as a group of scientists, as
palynologists and paleobotanists, owe a great deal
to Jim Canright for his dedication and foresight in
the early years of organizing our plans for the future.
Today we are enjoying the effort of Jim and his
colleagues through AASP and the IFPS.
Peggy Canright tells me that they have cremated
Jim’s remains, and for now his ashes will be placed
in his study, among his years of documents and
memorabilia (he discarded nothing!). Eventually,
following Jim’s wishes, the ashes will be strewn at
sea. Jim loved the Pacific Ocean, and he will remain
there forever. Although I was never a formal student
of Jim’s, I learned much from him. We shared many
professional and personal times. Jim was truly a
dear friend….I will miss him.
And Michael Farabee remembers………..
I first met Professor Canright when I was a student
in his Plant Morphology class. Taking his class
without the pre-requisite Plant Anatomy, I was
captivated by the methodical presentation of plants
in an evolutionary context, interspersed with stories
and anecdotes that made a dull subject (so my
friends told me) come alive. I returned to graduate
school; luckily Paleobotany and Palynology were
offered during the spring of 1980, so I signed up. To
my surprise Jim remembered me and when he
learned I was a graduate student, he quickly became
my advisor, signed me up for Palynology, supported
me in gaining regular graduate admission, and
eventually I became his teaching assistant. To get
me out of the lab, Jim invited me to play racquetball.
Despite giving several decades to me, Jim never
lost.
During one of those games he spoke of the academic
life, encouraging me to think beyond the Master’s
and go for a Ph.D. This push from the nest (Jim told
me that three degrees from ASU would not be a
good thing, and that I needed to experience new
settings and labs) led me to doctoral work with John Skvarla and L.R. Wilson at the University of
Oklahoma, and then to a post-doc with Tom and
Edith Taylor at The Ohio State University. Through it
all Jim remained a friendly correspondent as my
career progressed. From Jim I learned to steer my
course by my own bearing, ignoring the currents
and opinions that would way-lay me. I learned the
value of passion and caring about the science of
botany and palynology, to be organized and set
rules that would allow others to follow in my wake.
As the founding science faculty member at Estrella
Mountain Community College I have held to these
ideas.
Michael Zavada recalls as well…..
In 1971, I was in my second baseball season at the
best baseball program in the country— Arizona
State University. I managed to squeeze in some
education between the long, physically demanding
practices. It had been my high school dream to be
tutored by the blunt and no nonsense, three-time
national champion Coach Bobby Winkles who was
to show me the way to professional sports and
success. It was the same year that I met the blunt
and no nonsense Jim Canright. Jim’s obvious
intelligence and experience, coupled with his lucid
way of delivering his intended message, always
caused you to pause and to reflect. Jim demanded
hard work, a disciplined mind, stick-to-itiveness,
intelligence and nothing less than excellence. Jim
was the Bobby Winkles of Botany. There was never
any doubt that Jim had my well being and
development as a thinking person at the core of his
demands and advice. Despite the lavish resources
and the national reputation of the ASU baseball
program, it was Jim who changed my life. He taught
me the meaning of quality of life. He put me on a path
that provided an outstanding living, adventure, travel,
a greater appreciation of the wonder of the natural
world, and the challenge of the academic life. I had
the pleasure of knowing Jim for thirty-seven years
and my appreciation for the significance that he
played in my life at a crucial time and my affection for
him have grown over the years. It was just about a
week before Jim passed away that I received a
newspaper clipping from him about Clint Myers, a
successful women’s softball coach at ASU who
was my teammate and formidable competition as
a catcher at ASU. Jim asked me if I had regrets about
taking the career path that I have, rather than exploring
the possibilities in professional sports. Jim, I have
no regret, and I thank you for being an honest, fair
and caring educator and friend. I will miss you.
-David M. Jarzen, with contributions from Michael
Zavada and Michael Farabee
Personalia
Peter Raven Elected to National Geographic Board of Trustees
Botanist and conservationist Dr. Peter H. Raven,
president of the Missouri Botanical Garden, has
been appointed to the National Geographic Society
board of trustees, along with investment banker
Tracy Wolstencroft of Greenwich, Conn., a partner
at Goldman Sachs. They join 19 other trustees who
are leaders in science, education, law, business,
finance, government and public service.
The 120-year-old Society, whose mission is to
inspire people to care about the planet, is one of the
world’s largest nonprofit scientific and educational
organizations. It reaches more than 300 million
people each month through six magazines, National
Geographic Channel, television documentaries,
radio, music, films, books, DVDs, maps, school
publishing programs, interactive media and
expeditions. It has funded nearly 9,000 scientific
research projects and supports an education
program combating geographic illiteracy.
“National Geographic is fortunate to have the
additional counsel and experience of Peter Raven
and Tracy Wolstencroft, who have impressive
records of leadership and service in the conservation
and finance fields and to National Geographic,”
said John Fahey, Society president and CEO.
Raven is one of the world’s leading botanists and
advocates of conservation and biodiversity. Under
his 36-year leadership, the Missouri Botanical
Garden has become a world-class center for
botanical research, education and horticultural
display. Raven is also chairman of the National
Geographic Society’s Committee for Research and
Exploration, which awards grants for field-based
scientific research around the world.
Described by Time magazine as a “Hero for the
Planet,” Raven champions research around the
globe to preserve endangered plants and animals
and is an advocate for building a sustainable
environment. He has received numerous prizes
and awards in recognition of his work in science
and conservation, including the National Medal of
Science, the highest award for scientific
accomplishment in the United States; the
International Prize for Biology from the government
of Japan; Environmental Prize of the Institute de la
Vie; Volvo Environment Prize; the Tyler Prize for
Environmental Achievement; the Sasakawa Prize;
and the International Cosmos Prize, Osaka.
He served for 12 years as home secretary of the
National Academy of Sciences, to which he was elected in 1977. He is also a member of the
American Academy of Arts and Sciences and of the
American Philosophical Society.
Raven is co-editor of Flora of China, a joint Chinese-
American international project that is producing a
50-volume account of the roughly 31,000 species of
plants in China. He has written numerous books
and publications and is senior author of Biology of
Plants, the internationally best-selling textbook in
botany, now in its seventh edition, and Environment,
a leading textbook on the environment, now in its
sixth edition.
Raven received his Ph.D. from the University of
California, Los Angeles, in 1960, after completing
undergraduate work at the University of California,
Berkeley. He holds honorary degrees from a number
of universities around the world.
Peter Raven wins BBVA Foundation Award for Conservation Biology
Peter H. Raven, president of the Missouri Botanical Garden, will receive the
Award for Scientific Research in Ecology and Conservation Biology, a 500,000
euro prize, from the BBVA Foundation Awards for Biodiversity Conservation. Raven
is a co-recipient with Harold Mooney, professor of Environmental Biology at
Stanford University.
The BBVA Foundation Awards - whose global prize money of over one million euros
is the highest of its kind internationally - recognize and support the work
of the scientific community, organizations and professionals devoted to biodiversity
conservation. The awards exemplify the foundation's commitment to sustainable
development and improved quality of life. They will be presented in Madrid.
The BBVA Foundation's international jury grants the Award for Scientific Research
in Ecology and Conservation Biology to scientists in any country who have significantly
advanced the boundaries of knowledge in this field. Raven and Mooney were recognized
for "their outstanding contributions to understanding the evolutionary
and co-evolutionary processes that shape the adaptations of plants, the communities
they form, and the diversity and biogeography of those communities, and how
plants contribute to ecosystem function. Both lead the world in their understanding
of, and raising concerns about, the loss of plant diversity through habitat
destruction and invasive species, and in seeking ways to prevent biodiversity
loss."
The contributions of these two eminent scientists have been vital to the shift
in perspective that has taken place in conservation biology research, away from
a species-centered approach to one based on ecosystems and the services they
provide to humanity.
The jury also singled out their joint contribution to improving knowledge and
awareness regarding loss of biodiversity due to habitat destruction and the
action of invasive species, along with their invaluable work in the search for
strategies to halt this loss.
Raven is an eminent plant scientist and evolutionary biologist. The Missouri
Botanical Garden is one of the world's leading centers for botanical research
and training. Raven is the author of key contributions to the biological sciences
field; among them the co-evolution concept which he formulated on the basis
of his studies into butterflies and the plants they feed on. He has authored
over 450 articles in scientific journals and is editor or co-editor of 18 books,
some of which have become basic textbooks in plant biology and environmental
science. He has been cited in scientific papers on more than 5,000 occasions.
Charles Darwin’s Work with Plants Will Be Brought to Life
at The New York Botanical Garden
Darwin’s Garden: An Evolutionary Adventure
April 25–June 15, 2008
Exhibition Highlights Darwin’s Little-Known Fascination
with Plants
The untold story of Charles Darwin’s lifelong fascination and work with
plants, including how flowers have evolved their extreme beauty and how plants
are sensitive creatures responding to the least beam of sunlight and the pull
of gravity, will be presented in an exhibition entitled Darwin’s Garden:
An Evolutionary Adventure at The New York Botanical Garden this spring.
Darwin’s Garden will include exhibitions of living plants and historical
documents in three Botanical Garden venues: the Enid A. Haupt Conservatory,
LuEsther T. Mertz Library gallery, and Everett Children’s Adventure Garden,
plus an “evolutionary tour” of living plants demonstrating key points
on the evolutionary tree of life. It will paint a portrait of Darwin as a naturalist
and plantsman and show how Darwin’s botanical experiments and discoveries
helped shape his contributions to the understanding of life in general.
Darwin historian David Kohn, Ph.D., comments, “Only in his work as a
botanist can we truly see all the dimensions of Darwin as a scientist—that
is as a successful collector, as a powerful theorist, as an insightful observer,
and as a rigorous and almost prophetic experimenter.” Professor Kohn is
curating the exhibition in the Mertz Library and advising on the other components
of Darwin’s Garden.
There will be several events and programs associated with Darwin’s Garden,
most notably a symposium with leading Darwin scholars in early May.
Darwin’s Own Garden Re-created
The exhibition in the Haupt Conservatory will focus on Darwin’s work
with living plants, evoking Darwin’s own gardens, greenhouse, and experimental
beds where he conducted botanical research. It will tell the story of how careful
observation of the plants in his gardens and greenhouse inspired Darwin’s
groundbreaking thinking about natural selection and evolution. The exhibition
will re-create Darwin’s gardens at Down House, his home in England, and
the surrounding orchards and meadows where the naturalist made many further
scientific observations. Primroses, insectivorous plants, orchids, and climbing
plants, subjects of Darwin’s research and writings, will be featured in
the exhibition. Other plants will illustrate the role plants played in the evolution
of Darwin’s ideas and will bring to life the kitchen garden at Down House
as well as the famous “sandwalk” where Darwin made careful observation
of nature and plants, the basis for much of his break-through thinking.
Displays of plants will evoke Darwin’s experimental studies and his investigations
into pollination and the power of movement in plants.
Darwin’s Garden in the Haupt Conservatory will run April 25–June
15, 2008.
Darwin’s Botany in His Own Words
The exhibition in the Mertz Library’s William D. Rondina and Giovanni
Foroni LoFaro Gallery will include original historical documents exploring Darwin’s
deep personal relationship with plants, beginning in childhood. It will interweave
information about Darwin as a person with the story of his rich botanical ideas,
featuring Darwin’s own writings and collections. Illustrated books, manuscripts,
and other historical documents will offer insight into his thinking and demonstrate
the importance of botany throughout his life. Most of the materials come from
Darwin’s own manuscripts in Cambridge University Library and from the
Mertz Library’s extensive collection of 19th-century botanical works.
Additional materials will be on loan from the University Herbarium at Cambridge,
the Royal Horticultural Society’s Lindley Library in London, and the Archives
at the Harvard Botany Libraries.
The exhibition will start with Darwin’s botanical heritage, his family
history, and upbringing and proceed through his exposure to 18th- and early
19th-century botany in his undergraduate education at Edinburgh and Cambridge.
It will also illustrate the significant role of plants on his historic, five-year
journey around the world on the HMS Beagle. He spent much of his time collecting
plants along with fossil bones and bird skins. Darwin’s collections of
“all plants in flower” from the Galápagos Islands, for example,
became the basis for the first flora of that archipelago and provided his strongest
evidence for evolution. His field notes on the vegetation of Brazil and Tierra
del Fuego reflect his developing thinking on natural processes.
The exhibition will also chronicle Darwin’s professional friendships
and intellectual exchange with leading botanists of the era, including Joseph
Dalton Hooker, Director of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, and Asa Gray at Harvard
University, and show how these contributed to the creation of The Origin of
Species. It will also highlight his elegant and profound investigations into
plant sexuality (the role of flowers, including pollination and co-evolution
of plants and their pollinators) and sensitivity (how plants respond to touch,
light, gravity, and chemical substances).
Darwin’s Garden in the Mertz Library will be open April 25–July
20, 2008.
Children’s Adventures with Darwin
In the Everett Children’s Adventure Garden, an interactive exhibition
including plants important to the development of the concept of evolution will
invite hands-on exploration. Carnivorous plants will also be on display. Darwin
the man will be brought to life through a re-creation of his research laboratory,
an assortment of his working tools, a child-friendly timeline of the highlights
of Darwin’s life, and a replica of the Beagle, together with a map of
the ship’s five-year voyage to South America and around the world.
The exhibition and programs in the Children’s Adventure Garden will be
open April 25–June 29, 2008.
Scientific Symposium
The New York Botanical Garden, in collaboration with the American Museum of
Natural History, will also host a symposium on two evenings during the exhibition.
Entitled Darwin: 21st-Century Perspectives, the symposium will feature presentations
by scientists, historians, philosophers, and environmentalists—the current
thinking by some of the world’s leading Darwin experts. Because Darwin’s
theories continue to be a significant force in the world today, the symposium
will offer an extraordinary opportunity to hear top scholars and commentators
discuss Darwin’s far-reaching impact.
The two-part symposium, moderated by prominent naturalist and author Edward
O. Wilson, Ph.D., will be open to the public. It begins the evening of Tuesday,
May 6, at the Botanical Garden; the second session, the evening of Thursday,
May 8, will be at the American Museum of Natural History.
Symposium Admission: $10 each/$16 for both sessions
Free to Members of AMNH and NYBG; registration required
Please call 800.322.6924 for information and to purchase tickets
Evolutionary Tour, Workshops, and More
From April 25 to June 15, an Evolutionary Tour will take visitors on a scavenger
hunt through the tree of life among living plants in the Garden’s collections.
In the Haupt Conservatory and surrounding outdoor plantings, this approximately
40-minute walking tour will highlight significant plants in the evolutionary
tree of life. It will be accompanied by signage and commentary accessible via
visitors’ cell phones.
A separate audiotour will also be available to guide visitors through their
visit of Darwin’s Garden in the Haupt Conservatory and Mertz Library.
Weekend programs will feature drop-in lectures, workshops, and guided tours.
In addition, performances will feature music and poetry from Darwin’s
era, much of it heavily influenced by nature.
About Darwin and Plants
Botany played a pivotal role in each phase of the life of Charles Robert Darwin
(February 12, 1809–April 19, 1882). As an undergraduate he collected specimens
for his botany professor’s herbarium while geologizing in Wales. Voyaging
aboard the HMS Beagle he wrote in his journal that his mind was “a chaos
of delight” as he reveled in the luxuriance of tropical forests. Preparing
to write The Origin of Species, he treated his primroses with guano to produce
mutants. He tested by botanical experiments many of the critical arguments crucial
to the development of this seminal work. For decades afterward, he turned his
home and the surrounding countryside into a botanical field station and took
great pleasure in his experimental gardening.
In the spring of 1860, a year after The Origin of Species was published, Darwin
began plant experiments at Down House that resulted in six books that forever
recast the field of botany and provided solid evidence for Darwin’s theories
of evolutionary adaptation. The books are Fertilisation of Orchids (1862), Climbing
Plants (1865), Insectivorous Plants (1875), Forms of Flowers (1877), The Effects
of Cross and Self Fertilisation in the Vegetable Kingdom (1876), and The Power
of Movement in Plants (1880).
Darwin’s work with plants provided credible and enduring evidence in
support of his theory of evolution through natural selection. His studies on
the fertilization of orchids, insectivorous plants, climbing plants, and the
movements of plants were each a precise example of how evolution could solve
the traditional mysteries of natural history. He laid the foundation of modern
botany as an evolutionary discipline, which continues even today.
Darwin’s studies of living plants also led to a succession of brilliant
revelations. Through careful observation of insect pollination, for example,
he concluded that the two different but stable forms of the wild cowslip, Primula
veris, discourage self-fertilization of the plant and guarantee cross-fertilization.
He revealed that flowering plants attained their form and cross-fertilizing
function to sustain genetic variability. Darwin also became an expert on virtually
every British species of orchid. He discovered and demonstrated that the key
to orchid pollination was the touch of an insect’s proboscis, which releases
spring-loaded pollen. From this breakthrough Darwin structured a convincing
argument for adaptation by natural selection.
Through scientific explorations of botanical sex and sensitivity, Darwin projected
a dynamic conception of nature that would substantially enrich both scientific
and humanistic pursuits. And he contended that plants—no less than animals—are
sensitive creatures in possession of behaviors that permit them to respond to
their environment, including elements such as sunlight, touch, and gravity.
Plants clamber over neighbors, track the movement of the sun, capture and digest
insects, and respond to the “touch from a child’s hair.” Darwin
delighted in discovering these adaptations.
Exhibition Leadership
The New York Botanical Garden is proud to have historian David Kohn, Ph.D.,
a renowned Darwin expert and Professor Emeritus at Drew University, as curator
of Darwin’s Garden: An Evolutionary Adventure. John Parker, Ph.D., Professor
of Plant Cytogenetics and Director of the Cambridge University Botanic Garden,
is Advisor to The New York Botanical Garden on the project. In addition, an
Advisory Committee of distinguished Darwin scholars will contribute a wide range
of intellectual perspectives. Senior New York Botanical Garden staff, including
Vice President for Horticulture and Living Collections Todd Forrest, Mertz Library
Director Susan Fraser, Vice President for Education Jeff Downing, and Vice President
for Laboratory Research Dennis Wm. Stevenson, Ph.D., round out the leadership
of this comprehensive exhibition.
After the exhibition at The New York Botanical Garden, portions of Darwin’s
Garden: An Evolutionary Adventure will be displayed at the Huntington
Botanical Garden in Pasadena, California.
PRIMING SCIENTISTS FOR SUCCESSFUL MEDIA INTERVIEWS
New AIBS book provides tools and tips for effective science communication
WASHINGTON, DC. Evolution, climate change, stem cell research-Scientists are
frequently called upon to provide expert information on hot button issues that
pervade the daily news headlines, yet most find themselves woefully unprepared
for the bright lights of the television studio or leading questions from a newspaper
journalist. A new publication from the American Institute of Biological Sciences
(AIBS), Communicating Science: A Primer for Working with the Media, by Holly
Menninger and Robert Gropp, will prepare scientists for successful and effective
media interviews.
Recognizing that many scientists are reluctant to engage in media outreach,
the Primer outlines compelling reasons for scientists to interact with the media
and describes key differences between journalism and science that may not be
apparent to practicing scientists. Step-by-step, Menninger and Gropp walk scientists
through the entire interview process-from appropriate questions to ask when
a reporter calls to practical advice for looking and sounding one's best on-air
or on-camera.
The information and advice in the Primer is presented in eight easy-to-read
chapters that provide vital information for scientists new to media outreach,
as well as a quick refresher for seasoned experts-an ideal text for a graduate
course on science communication or a professional development course for students
and faculty. The Primer's authors speak from their own experiences as PhD scientists
in the biological sciences with years of experience in media outreach.
The concise, user-friendly volume has several unique features that set it apart
from other media guides for scientists. The Primer includes first-person interviews
with nearly a dozen scientists who have successfully navigated print, radio,
and television interviews. The scientists-including the "Island Snake Lady,"
Kristin Stanford, recently featured on the Discovery Channel show, Dirty Jobs-share
advice and experiences on a number of topics, including safely speaking on behalf
of an organization, avoiding trouble when discussing socially or politically
controversial topics, and reflections on first interviews.
The Primer also provides worksheets to assist readers with interview preparation:
building a message framework with talking points and transition phrases, developing
analogies, and using illustrative props or images. It includes pages for readers
to organize contact information of journalists with whom they have worked directly
and those who have reported on stories related to their own research to keep
as potential contacts for future story pitches.
Communicating Science: A Primer for Working with the Media is available now
at www.aibs.org/bookstore/.
The table of contents and cover image are also available at www.aibs.org/bookstore/.
THREE HIGH HORTICULTURAL HONORS FOR THE MISSOURI BOTANICAL GARDEN
The Missouri Botanical Garden has added one statewide and two national recognitions
to its growing list of awards for horticultural excellence. Three trees have
been declared State Champions by the Missouri Department of Conservation (MDC).
The oak collection has been certified as a North American Plant Collections
Consortium (NAPCC) Collection by the American Public Gardens Association (APGA).
The extensive daffodil collection has been named the first American Daffodil
Society (ADS) Display Garden.
"These recognitions demonstrate the wonderful treasure that the Missouri
Botanical Garden and its plants are to the metro St. Louis region," said
Jim Cocos, vice president of horticulture. "Our valued State Champion trees
reflect the fact that our institution has been here for almost 150 years. The
national recognition of our oak and daffodil collections reflects the strength
and breadth of our plant collections, which are prized for their diversity and
quality."
The Champion Tree program recognizes the largest tree of each species living
in Missouri. Size is calculated using a formula developed by American Forests
and the MDC that takes into account a tree's height, crown spread and trunk
circumference. The Garden now holds the record for the biggest white basswood
(Tilia heterophylla), western soapberry (Sapindus drummondii), and possumhaw
(Ilex decidua) in the state. All are native Missouri species.
The deciduous white basswood is often used for landscaping and known for its
sweet, bee-attracting flowers. Towering above the Museum Building, the Garden's
tree is 103 feet tall with an 81-foot spread. The 52-foot tall western soapberry,
near the Lehmann Rose Garden, has glossy green leaves which turn a showy yellow-gold
in autumn. Its name comes from the chemicals in its fruits, which lather like
soap in water but can also be toxic. The possumhaw is a much smaller deciduous
shrub which displays colorful orange-red berries throughout winter. The average
possumhaw is just seven to 15 feet tall with a five- to 12-foot spread. The
champion possumhaw, located across from the Museum Building, is 18 feet tall
with a 33-foot crown spread.
The Garden has also been honored by the APGA as a partner in the first multi-site
Quercus (oak) collection to achieve official NAPCC Member Status.
"Your organization stands among a prestigious group of gardens and arboreta
that have committed themselves to the conservation and care of specific plant
collections curated at the highest professional level," said Pamela Allenstein,
NAPCC coordinator.
The Garden joins 14 other institutions nationwide that will collaborate to
strengthen their unified collection and preserve plant diversity. They will
make tree data and germplasm (plant genetic material) available to each other
for evaluation, selection, breeding and various other research purposes. The
Garden's collection includes 385 individual oak trees representing 48 different
taxa, or categories.
The American Daffodil Society has awarded the Missouri Botanical Garden's Narcissus
(daffodil) collection as the first sanctioned ADS Display Garden. Certified
collections must include not only a large number but also a wide variety of
daffodils for public display and education; meet various criteria for plant
signage and garden maintenance; and undergo bi-annual reviews by the ADS.
The Narcissus collection located in the Samuels and Heckman Bulb Gardens showcases
nearly 650 unique varieties, representing 12 of the 13 horticultural divisions.
The collection includes a number of historic varieties and a selection of daffodils
hybridized in Missouri. Visitors can learn about the plants on display through
interpretive signage and detailed labeling specialized for the collection. Blooming
season runs from late February through April, with peak bloom usually in early
April.
The 79-acre Missouri Botanical Garden is open from 9 a.m. to
5 p.m. daily at 4344 Shaw Blvd. in south St. Louis. Admission
is $8 adults (St. Louis City and County residents, $4 adults,
$2 seniors). Children 12 and under are free. Special rates apply
for some events and amenities. Visit www.mobot.org
for details or call the recorded line at (314) 577-9400.
Books Reviewed
1. The Ecology and Evolution
of Ant-Plant Interactions
2. Plants of Longevity
- The Medicinal Flora of Vilcabamba. Plantas de Longevidad - La
flora Curcandera de Vilcabamba and
Plants of
the Four Winds - The Magic and Medicinal Flora of Peru. Plantas
de los Cuatro Vientos - Flora Mágica y Medicinal del Perú
3. Cacti of Texas, a field guide:
with emphasis on the Trans-Pecos species
4. Electron Microscopy, Methods and
Protocols, Second Edition
1. The Ecology and Evolution of Ant-Plant Interactions.
Rico-Gray, Victor and Paulo S. Oliveira. 2007. ISBN 9780226713472
(cloth US$70.00); ISBN 9780226713489 (paper US$28.00), xiii +
331 pp. University of Chicago Press, 1427 East 60th Street, Chicago,
Illinois 60637, USA
Plants are the autotrophic basis of life on Earth, and ants –
in terms of abundance and biomass – are, in E.O. Wilson’s
words, “the little things that run the world”. Thus
it should come as no surprise that the rich variety of interactions
between ants and plants continues to captivate botanists and entomologists,
ecologists and evolutionary biologists, and keen observers of
natural history. For nearly fifty years, ecological and evolutionary
approaches to the study and analysis of ant-plant interactions
have been framed by Janzen’s classic study of the mutualism
between ants and acacias (Janzen 1966) and the subsequent elaboration
of a general theory of coevolution by John Thompson (1982, 1994).
In their new book, The Ecology and Evolution of Ant-Plant Interactions,
Victor Rico-Gray and Paulo Oliviera provide a comprehensive and
readable overview of the hundreds of studies of ant-plant interactions
conducted since Janzen (1966) and illustrate clearly how well
Thompson’s framework for understanding coevolution has supported
the field.
After a quick introduction to the evolutionary history of ants
and plants, and a brief review of the fossil record of ants, Rico-Gray
and Oliviera focus their monograph on the two best-studied types
of interactions between ants and plants: antagonistic interactions
and mutualistic interactions. In particular, they work within
the conceptual framework in which mutualism evolvies from antagonistic
interactions, and that places both within the context of relationships
between consumers and their resources (Holland et al. 2005). This
context serves Rico-Gray and Oliviera well, as they move seamlessly
from a consideration of clear antagonistic interactions (leaf-cutting
and seed harvesting by ants), through mutualisms as extensions
of antagonism (ants as primary and secondary seed dispersers),
to pure mutualisms in which plants feed and house ants that in
return feed the plants and defend them from herbivores. In between,
are the conditional mutualisms, both direct and indirect.
The directly conditional mutualisms are characterized by the
broad range of associations found among ants and their host plants,
including acacias, Cecropia, Piper, and Macaranga, to name only
a few. Some of these ant-plant interactions are very elaborate,
and include species-specific domatia and food bodies provided
by the plant, which in return is strongly defended by the ants.
Others are more general, and revolve around extrafloral nectaries
or limited provisioning of food resources. Given the spatial scattering
of many ant-plants, the heterogeneous spatial arrangement of ant
nests and their foraging strategies, and the opportunistic and
facultative nature of most associations between ants and plants,
Rico-Gray and Oliviera conclude that species-specific coevolution
between particular ants and particular plant species is likely
to be the exception rather than the rule. This conclusion is supported
by the preponderance of evidence presented in their book.
The indirect mutualisms are perhaps more interesting to community
ecologists such as myself who are interested in complex webs of
interacting species. These interactions involve plants, phloem-feeding
herbivores (primarily hemipterans) or other honeydew-secreting
insects (butterfly larvae and some gallmaking wasps), and the
ants that tend these herbivores. Here the conditional nature of
the net interaction between ants and plants is most evident. Ants
that tend hemipterans (for example) increase the latter’s
abundance and survival rate, and since hemipterans can reduce
plant growth and survival, there is the potential for insect-tending
ants to indirectly and negatively affect the host plant. But,
if the ants also provide protection to the plants, and if that
benefit outweighs the negative impact of the herbivores, then
the net result will be and indirect positive effect of ants on
plants. A further twist is added by plants that bear extrafloral
nectaries. In some cases, such nectaries may benefit herbivores
by attracting ants to tend them whereas in others extrafloral
nectaries are thought to have evolved as a defense against ant-herbivore
mutualisms.
The existence of ant-plant mutualisms has suggested some strategies
for biological control. Rico-Gray and Oliveira highlight work
done by Perfecto (1991) on using ants to control pests in small-scale
maize-based agroecosystems in Nicaragua, and by Vandermeer et
al. (2002) in coffee plantations in Mexico. While these two examples
are compelling, neither biological control nor chemical control
of pests should be used indiscriminately.
Much remains to be learned about interactions between ants and
plants, and in their concluding overview of the field, Rico-Gray
and Oliveira highlight a broad range of open questions and research
topics. These include additional focus on spatial and temporal
variability (moving beyond studies of single species in single
populations for short times); better assessment of alternative
defense strategies by plants (are the ants really necessary?);
stronger quantification of indirect costs and benefits in ant
– ant-tended-herbivore – plant systems; more attention
to direct feeding of plants by ants; detailed consideration of
the other arthropods in the system and elaboration of networks
of interactions; and better use of phylogenetic information. This
book should successfully generate many undergraduate projects,
masters’ theses, and doctoral dissertation topics, and should
be on the shelf of any botanist, entomologist, ecology, or evolutionary
biologist interested in interactions between the organisms that
have built the world and those that run it.
Literature Cited
Holland, J. N., J. H. Ness, A. Boyle, and J. Bronstein. 2005.
Mutualisms as consumer resource interactions. Pp. 17-35 in P.
Barbosa and I. Castellanos, editors. Ecology of predator-prey
interactions. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
Janzen, D. H. 1966. Coevolution of mutualism between ants and
acacias in Central America. Evolution 20: 249-275.
Perfecto, I. 1991. Ants (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) as natural control
agents of pests in irrigated maize in Nicaragua. Journal of
Economic Entomology 84: 65-70.
Thompson, J. N. 1982. Interaction and coevolution. John
Wiley & Sons, New York, New York.
Thompson, J. N. 1994. The coevolutionary process. University
of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois.
Vandermeer, J., I, Perfecto, G. Ibarra Nuñez, S. Philpott,
and A. García Ballinas. 2002. Ants (Azteca sp.) as potential
biological control agents in shade coffee production in Chiapas,
Mexico. Agroforestry Systems 56: 271-276.
– Aaron M. Ellison, Harvard University,
Harvard Forest, 324 North Main Street, Petersham, Massachusetts
01366 USA (aellison @ fas.harvard.edu)
2. Plants of Longevity - The Medicinal Flora of Vilcabamba.
Plantas de Longevidad - La flora Curcandera de Vilcabamba.
Bussmann, Rainer W. and Douglas Sharon. 2007. ISBN 0-9789962-2-4
(Paper US$ 14.95) 253 pp. Graficart, srl, Jiron San Martin 375,
Trujillo, Peru.
Plants of the Four Winds - The Magic and Medicinal Flora
of Peru. Plantas de los Cuatro Vientos - Flora Mágica y
Medicinal del Perú. Bussmann, Rainer W. and Douglas
Sharon. 2007. ISBN 0-9789962-3-2 (Paper US$29.95) 596 pp. Graficart,
srl, Jiron San Martin 375, Trujillo, Peru.
These two books present the culmination of a number of years'
worth of ethnobotanical research among herb vendors and traditional
healers (curanderos) in Northwest Peru (Departments of Piura,
Lambayeque, La Libertad, Cajamarca, and San Martin) and among
curanderos and midwives of Southern Ecuador (Loja Province). Presented
in a straightforward, bilingual (Spanish and English) format,
both volumes are generously illustrated with black-and-white photographs
and/or herbarium scans of nearly all of the plants they discuss,
along with details of the preparation and uses of the medicinal
flora of their respective regions. Introductory overviews of the
historical and current status of traditional medicine in these
regions as well as a list of the most commonly-encountered medical
conditions, including illnesses of supernatural origin, round
out these volumes.
Plants of the Four Winds presents data on almost 500 plant species
used in Northern Peru, and Plants of Longevity contains data for
almost 200 plant species from Loja Province, Ecuador. Native species
make up the majority of the plants presented in both volumes,
although naturalized plants represent around 20% of the total.
The regions covered in these two volumes are geographically contiguous,
but the species that are presented differ substantially; even
where there is species overlap, medicinal use can be significantly
different. All of the plants under discussion have been vouchered
in herbaria in their respective countries. Nomenclature of the
Ecuadorean material follows that of the Catalog of the Vascular
Plants of Ecuador, while nomenclature of the Peruvian material
follows that of the Catalog of the Flowering Plants and Gymnosperms
of Peru.
Ordered alphabetically by Family, Genus and species, vernacular
names are presented for each species, along with plant part used,
route of administration, preparation, medicinal use(s) and voucher
numbers for each collection. These volumes take a decidedly plant-based
approach to organization in the classical "cookbook"
style of documentary ethnobotany. The inclusion of a disclaimer
of liability by the authors for injury caused by use of the plants
found in these books underscores this point.
Although the introductory sections of both volumes touch briefly
on historical and social aspects of local and regional medicinal
plant use, the broader significance of this rich and poorly-studied
component of the Andean flora is only obliquely referred to. The
value of this research, and these books, in this context are extremely
high.
Unfortunately, referring to these works will be made somewhat
difficult by the cryptic style of the of publication date.
– James G. Graham, Adjunct Professor of
Pharmacognosy, University of Illinois at Chicago and Research
Associate, Department of Botany, The Field Museum, Chicago Illinois
3. Cacti of Texas, a field guide: with emphasis on the
Trans-Pecos species. A. Michael Powell, James F. Weedin,
and Shirley A. Powell. 400 pages, 314 color photos, 124 maps,
ISBN?978-0-89672-611-6, $24.95 paper.
Powell & Weedin converted their extraordinary 2004 treatise
Cacti of the Trans-Pecos and Adjacent Areas into an equally superb
abridged version, a.k.a. field guide. See my review of their 2004
treatise in PSB 51(3): 110-112, which largely also applies to
their 2008 field guide. In fact, due to some new photos, one additional
co-author (Shirley Powell), and an especially seamless integration
of figures with text, the field guide is better than expected.
For each cactus taxon from Trans-Pecos Texas, the area between
the Rio Grande and Rio Pecos, the authors not only include a relatively
jargon-free description of the plant (so good that the glossary
seems superfluous), habitat, and etymology, but also decent-sized
photos of flowers and fruits, as well as a distribution map. All
other cactus taxa in Texas are briefly described, including taxa
native to the remainder of the state and introduced species. For
any botanist traveling through west Texas, especially Big Bend,
this is an invaluable field guide written by the true experts.
This volume is in a slightly larger format (6 x 9 inches, 15.25
x 22.75 cm) than many people would like to carry into the field.
This could have been improved by moving the figure captions out
of the margins, decreasing the spacing between lines of text,
and shrinking the distribution maps.
Use of ploidy levels in the keys provides a difficult character
for use in the field, unless you carry a microscope with you.
On the other hand, while ploidy levels in the key of Echinocereus
seem unnecessary, ploidy may provide the best or only way of keying
out the confounding prickly pears, i.e. genus Opuntia s.s.
Cacti of Texas, a field guide is fairly error-free. I only spotted
a few production errors, such as incorrect page reference to Coryphantha
minima in the keys. Many combinations in this field guide supposedly
will be published in a forthcoming chapter by Zimmerman et al.
Unfortunately, one of Zimmerman’s co-authors passed away
over a decade ago, so these combinations may not be forthcoming
any time soon. However, all in all, these are minor foibles in
a beautiful field guide.
– Root Gorelich, Carleton University,
Ottawa, Canada.
4. Electron Microscopy, Methods and Protocols, Second Edition.
Edited by John Kuo. Volume 369 in Methods in Molecular Biology.
Humana Press, Totowa, NJ. 608 pp. ISBN 13:978-1-58829-573-6
Who needs this book? Searching Amazon.com for "electron
microscopy methods" returns 2,100 hits. If you are a person
who suddenly decides to do a spot of ultrastructure, you won't
turn to this book. Instead you would turn to your friendly neighborhood
core facility for electron microscopy to be trained, possibly
tormented, in the fine art of whatever subgenera is needed. On
the other hand, if you are the director of said core facility
and a customer, I mean a colleague, comes to you saying "Help,
I need to look at xylem by cryoplaning" then you could pull
Electron Microscopy Methods and Protocols off the shelf and turn
to the chapter on cryoplaning and get a good start on figuring
out what it was all about. Like all of the chapters, you would
read an overview of the method but also find step by step instructions,
complete with lists of materials and reagents, where to buy them,
drawings and pictures of apparatus, representative images, and
even references for further information. You would be well on
your way to helping your client cryoplane or urging him or her
to go away.
Cryoplaning is a versatile but unusual method and is included
quite possibly in no other book on electron microscopy methods.
This reason alone may be enough to spur the insatiable collector
to buy the book. But as that chapter is ten pages out of the book's
607, what about the other chapters? The first 150 or so pages
(seven chapters) cover fairly well trodden ground, namely conventional
specimen preparation (i.e, fixation and embedding, including with
microwaves), ultramicrotomy, and staining (both positive and negative).
These are competent articles, but have little new and few citations
after the year 2000. The ultramicrotomy article (by Herbert Hagler)
fully describes that author's iconoclastic method for glass-knife
making and anyone who uses a lot of these, particularly for fine
work, might be game to try it. The next 14 chapters (the bulk
of the book) aim at more specialized applications. Several of
them include cryotechniques, with thorough chapters on high-pressure
freezing, cryoultramicrotomy, and immunostaining; other chapters
deal with quantitative immunostaining, tomography, crystal¬lography,
and even in situ hybridization (i.e. detecting nucleic acids based
on hybridization). The final 150 pages (seven chapters) are devoted
to scanning electron microscopy; PSL readers might be surprised
to hear that four of them deal specifically with plants. Included
here is a chapter by Brendan Griffin on variable pressure and
environmental methods that is particularly up to date and well
illustrated. Few electron microscopy labs will need to do all
of these protocols and few labs will be without books covering
some of them; but anyone lacking books on electron microscopy
would find this volume a reasonable addition.
The publisher makes a few odd choices. This is emphatically
a protocols book but because it is short and thick, you can't
keep it open without a third hand or lead brick, hence working
from it at the bench is all but impossible. Some of the articles
lend themselves naturally to the protocol format (i.e. a numbered
list of steps) but consider ultramicrotomy: this is a process,
not an assay, and the articles on it feel shoehorned into the
protocol boot. In some articles, there are single notes covering
two pages, and many articles contain dozens of notes, grouped
together before the references in each chapter. The book has micrographs
of the results of protocols properly executed but of almost no
failures; nevertheless, failures illuminate and it can helpful
to know what to avoid as well as what to seek. Finally, I am a
great fan of "the book" but I wonder whether the goal
of publishing methods would be better served by an internet-based
approach? Suppose each chapter were available for download at
a cost of $5.00 each? This number is roughly the price of the
book divided by the number of chapters. Arguably, if the book
weren't printed, the costs would be less and so perhaps each article
could sell for a dollar or two? Our gut reaction is to demand
anything on the www be free but yet be willing to shell out 150
dollars for a book in which we will use a couple of protocols.
With that in mind, why object to paying less than ten percent
of of the whole book's cost for the articles you want, downloaded
from the web?
Electron microscopy is a mix of high-wattage engineering and
low-tech inventiveness. It is fascinating to see the ingenuity
biologists have lavished on their samples, all for the sake of
seeing the unseen. This ingenuity permeates Electron Microscopy
Methods and Protocols, a book whose perusal will reward anyone
interested in putting some of this cleverness to work for them
or who wishes to compare their own practices to the devious devices
of the community of electron microscopists.
- Tobias Baskin, Biology Department, University
of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA, 01003
Books Received for Review
If you would like to review a book or books for PSB, contact
the Editor, stating the book of interest and the date by which
it would be reviewed (15 January, 15 April, 15 July or 15 October).
E-mail psb@botany.org, call,
or write as soon as you notice the book of interest in this list
because they go quickly! - Editor
| 1) |
Carolus Clusius: Towards a Cultural History of a
Renaissance Naturalist. Egmond, Florike, Paul Hoftijzer
and Robert Visser (eds). 2008. ISBN 90-6984-506-7 (Cloth US$75.00)
296 pp. The University of Chicago Press, 1427 East 60th Street,
Chicago, IL 60637-2954. |
OUT FOR
REVIEW |
| 2) |
The Curious World of Carnivorous Plants: A comprehensive
Guide to Their Biology and Cultivation. Barthlott,
Wilhelm, Stefan Porembski, Rüdiger Seine, and Inge Theisen.
2007. ISBN 978-0-88192-792-4 (Cloth US$39.95) 224 pp. Timber
Press, 133 S.W. Second Avenue, Suite 450, Portland, OR 97204-3527. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 3) |
Edible Medicines: An Ethnopharmacology of Food.
Etkin, Nina L. 2008. ISBN 978-0-8165-2748-9 (Paper US$24.95)
320 pp. The University of Arizona Press. 355 S. Euclid Avenue,
Suite 103, Tucson, AZ 85719. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 4) |
Field Guide to the Wild Orchids of Texas.
Brown, Paul Martin. 2008. ISBN 978-0-8130-3159-0 (Flex US$29.95.)
316 pp. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 5) |
Field guide to Wisconsin Sedges: An Introduction
to the Genus Carex (Cyperaceae). Hipp, Andrew
L. 2008. ISBN 978-0-299-22594-0 (Paper US$27.95) 280 pp. The
University of Wisconsin Press, 1930 Monroe Street, 3rd Floor,
Madison, Wisconsin 53711-2059. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 6) |
Fluorescing World of Plant Secreting Cells.
Roshchina, Victoria V. 2008. ISBN 978-1-57808-5156. (Cloth
US$88.00) 338 pp, Science Publishers, P.O. Box 699. Enfield,
New Hampshire 03748. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 7) |
Fruits and Plains: The Horticultural Transformation
of America. Pauly, Philip J. 2008. ISBN 978-0-674-02663-6
(Cloth US$39.95) 336 pp. Harvard University Press, 79 Garden
Street, Cambridge, MA 02138. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 8) |
Fungal Pathogenesis in Plant and Crops: Molecular
Biology and Host Defense Mechanisms, 2nd ed. Vidhyasekaran,
P. 2008. (Cloth US$169.95) 509 pp. CRC Press, Taylor &
Francis Group, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300, Boca
Raton, FL 33487-2742. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 9) |
The Garden Primer, 2nd ed. Damrosch, Barbara.
2008. ISBN 978-0-7611-2275-3 (Paper, US$18.95) 832 pp. Workman
Press, 225 Varick Street, New York, New York 10014. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 10) |
Gardens and Cultural Change: A Pan American Perspective.
Conan, Michel and Jeffrey Quilter (eds) 2008. ISBN 978-0-88402-330-2
(Paper US$25.00) 110 pp. Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and
Collection, distributed by Harvard University Press, 79.Garden
Street, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 11) |
Genetic Glass Ceilings: Transgenics for Crop Biodiversity.
Gressel, Jonathan. 2008. ISBN 978-0-8018-8719-2 (Cloth US$65.00)
461 pp. The Johns Hopkins University Press. 2715 N. Charles
Street, Baltimore, MD 21218. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 12) |
The Great Cacti: Ethonobotany and Biogeography.
Yetman, David. 2008. ISBN 978-0-8165-2431-0 (Cloth US$59.95)
320 pp. The University of Arizona Press, 355 S. Euclid Avenue,
Suite 103 Tucson, AZ 85719. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 13) |
An Introduction to Plant Breeding. Brown,
Jack and Peter Caligari. 2008. ISBN 978-1-4051-3344-9 (Paper
US$80.00) 209 pp. Blackwell Publishing, 2121 State Avenue,
Ames, Iowa 50014-8300. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 14) |
Middle East Garden Traditions: Unity and Diversity.
Conan, Michel (ed.) ISBN 978-0-88402-329-6 (Paper US$40.00)
363 pp. Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection, distributed
by Harvard University Press, 79.Garden Street, Cambridge,
Massachusetts 02138. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 15) |
Musa Cliffortiana: Clifford’s Banana Plant.
Linnaeus, Carl (translated by Stephen Freer). 2007. ISBN 978-3-906166-63-6
(Cloth US$124.00) 264 pp. A.R. G. Gantner Verlag K.G. Distributed
by Koeltz Scientific Books, P.O. Box 1360, D-61453 Koenigstein,
Germany. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 16) |
Nature’s Palette: The Science of Plant Color.
Lee, David. 2007. ISBN 0-226-47052-0. (Cloth US$35.00) 409pp.
The University of Chicago Press, 1427 East 60th Street, Chicago,
IL 60637-2954. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 17) |
Orchid Biology Reviews and Perspectives, IX.
Cameron, Kenneth M., Joseph Arditti, and Tiiu Kull (eds.).
2007. ISBN 0-89327-475-5. (Cloth US$85.00) 562pp. The New
York Botanical Garden Press, 200th Street and Kazimiroff Boulevard,
Bronx, New York, 10458-5126. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 18) |
Plant Bioinformatics: Methods and Protocols.
Edwards, David (ed.) 2007. ISBN 978-1-588-29-653-5 (Cloth
US$139.00) 552 pp. The Humana Press, Inc., 999 Riverview Drive,
Suite 208, Totowa, New Jersey 07512. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 19) |
The Seaweeds of Florida. Dawes, Clinton
J. and Arthur C. Mathieson. 2007. ISBN 978-0-8130-3148-4.
(Cloth US$100.00) 591pp University Press of Florida, 15 Northwest
15th Street. Gainesville, FL 32611-2079. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 20) |
Timber Press Pocket Guide to Palms. Riffle,
Robert Lee. 2008. ISBN 978-0-88192-776-4 (Flex US$19.95) 244
pp. Timber Press, Inc. 133 S.W. Second Avenue, Suite 450.
Portland, OR 97204-3527. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 21) |
Duke*s Handbook of Medicinal Plants of the Bible.
Duke, James A. with Peggy-Ann K. Duke and Judith L. duCellier.
2008. ISBN 978-0-8493-8202-4 (Cloth US$89.95) 528 pp. CRC
Press/Taylor & Francis Group, LLC. 6000 Broken Sound Parkway,
NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 22) |
Seed to Elegance: Kentia Palms of Norfolk Island,
South Pacific. Williams, Kevin. 2007. ISBN 978-0-9775121-1-9
(Paper US$24.95) 72 pp. Studio Monarch, Norfolk Island, 2899
South Pacific. |
Reviewer
Requested |
| 23) |
Gods and Goddesses in the Garden. Bernhardt,
Peter. 2008. ISBN 978-0-8135-4266-9 (Cloth US$24.95) 240 pp.
Rutgers University Press, 100 Joyce Kilmer Avenue, Piscataway,
NJ 08854-8099.
|
Reviewer
Requested |
| 24) |
Trees, Truffles, and Beasts: How Forests Function.
Maser, Chris, Andrew W. Claridge, and James M. Trappe. 2008.
ISBN 978-0-8135-4226-3 (Paper US$26.95) 288 pp. Rutgers University
Press, 100 Joyce Kilmer Avenue, Piscataway, NJ 08854-8099.
|
Reviewer
Requested |
| 25) |
Flora of the Northeast: A Manual of the Vascular
Flora of New England and Adjacent New York. 2nd ed.
Magee, Dennis W. and Harry E. Ahles. 2007. ISBN 978-1-55849-577-7
(Cloth US$95.00) 1264 pp. University of Massachusetts Press,
East Experiment Station, 671 North Pleasant St., Amherst,
MA 01003.
|
Reviewer
Requested |
| 26) |
Cacti of Texas: A Field Guide. Powell,
A. Michael, James F. Weedlin, and Shirley A. Powell. 2008.
ISBN 0-89672-611-8 (Paper US$24.95) 400 pp. Texas Tech University
Press, Box 41037, Lubbock, TX 79409-1037.
|
OUT FOR
REVIEW |
| 27) |
Ecology. Cain, Michael L., William D. Bowman, and Sally D. Hacker.
2008. ISBN 0-87893-083-3 (Cloth US$107.95) 621 pp. Sinauer
Associates, Inc. P.O. Box 407, Sunderland, MA 01375-0407.
|
Reviewer
Requested |
| 28) |
Ending the Mendel-Fisher Controversy. Franklin,
Allan, A.W. F. Edwards, Daniel J. Fairbanks, Daniel L. Hartl,
and Teddy Seidenfeld. 2008. ISBN 978-0-8229-5986-1 (Paper
US$27.95) 330 pp. University of Pittsburgh Press, Eureka Building,
Fifth Floor, 3400 Forbes Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15260.
|
Reviewer
Requested |
| 29) |
Woody Plants of the Southeastern U.S.: A Field Botany
Course on CD. Kirchoff, Bruce. 2008. ISBN 13:978-1-930723-62-7.
(CD US$27.00) Missouri Botanical Garden Press, P.O. Box 299,
St. Louis, Missouri 63166-0299.
|
Reviewer
Requested |
| 30) |
The Ladyslipper and I: The Autobiography of G. Ledyard
Stebbins. Stebbins, G. Ledyard. 2007. ISBN 978-1-930723-65-8
(Cloth US$$35.00) 173 pp. Missouri Botanical Garden Press,
P.O. Box 299, St. Louis, Missouri 63166-0299.
|
Reviewer
Requested |
|