Book Reviews: Briefly Noted

The Identification of Flowering Plant Families Cullen, J. 1997. ISBN 0-521-58485-X (cloth US$59.95) 0-521-58550-3 (paper US$21.95) 227 pp. Cambridge University Press, 40 West 20th Streeet, New York, NY 10011.
- The fourth edition of this small volume is to be welcomed. It is greatly enlarged and more user-friendly, mainly because the extensive abbreviations in the family descriptions have been removed. The first three editions were authored by Davis and Cullen and contained 260 families and 122 pages, 272 families and 113 pages, and 285 families and 133 pages, respectively. The new edition has 286 families (which is the new one?) and a whopping 215 pages and, like the third one, is arranged on the Engler and Prantl system. Some of the larger families (e.g. Liliaceae) have sub-keys and descriptions for the widely-recognized segregates within them, raising the actual number of treated families to 286 from the 258 with numbers. Who is the book aimed at? The subtitle tells it all. - P. Mick Richardson, Missouri Botanical Garden, St. Louis


The Plant-Book: A Portable Dictionary of the Vascular Plants Mabberly, D. J. 1997. ISBN 0521-41421-0 (cloth US$49.95) 858 pp. Cambridge University Press, 40 West 20th Streeet, New York, NY 10011. - If you are like me, your original 'Mabberley' is probably pretty worn out and you may wish to replace it. Now would be a good time. The new edition, published ten years after the original, contains almost 2,500 additional new entries and the systems of classification have also changed, largely to reflect recent treatments edited by Kubitzki. The system of Crabbe, Jermy and Mickel for the ferns and other basal vascular plants has been abandoned, as have large parts of Cronquist's 1981 system. A synopsis of the taxonomic arrangement (pages 771-781) is a useful 'time slice' of a mid-1990s classification. Curiously, the new edition has hard covers with squared corners and the pages now have crudely-rounded comers, versus the original soft and rounded covers with squared pages. The book weighs less than the original despite being 150 pages longer, becoming that little bit more portable. Send your congratulations to Mabberley by purchasing a copy. It may encourage him to produce a third edition. - P. Mick Richardson, Missouri Botanical Garden, St. Louis

Return to: | Table of Contents || Book Reviews Home Page || Previous Review || Next Page