PLANT SCIENCE BULLETIN
WINTER 2005 VOLUME 51 NUMBER 4
The Botanical Society of America: The Society for ALL Plant Biologists
Table of Contents
100th Anniversary Series
Harriet B. Creighton:
Proud Botanist
............................................................................118
News from the Society
The Power of Plants: Building Collaborations among Educational Institutions,
and Botanical Gardens Communities
.........................................................................................126
Is it Cool to Know and Do Science? Can We Create a Scientific Temper? Linking Scientists,
College Faculty, K-12 Teachers and their
Students in Collaborative Research
........................................127
Returning Biodiversity Knowledge and Information to Society: The Case of
Mexico
.................129
Dear
Botanical Society of America Members and Plant Science Bulletin Readers
................130
Botanical Society of America's Statement on Evolution
...............................................130
Intelligent Design: It's Not Even Wrong
.......................................................................130
Centennial
Medallion
....................................................................................................131
Letters ............................................................................................................................................132
Announcements
Personalia
Karla Meza Awarded Timothy Plowman Scholarship
..................................................132
Awards, Conferences, Meetings
2nd Meeting of the International Society for Phylogenetic Nomenclature
...........................132
Award Opportunities
Timothy C. Plowman Latin American Research Award;
Premio de investigación Latinoamericano Timothy C. Plowman. ........133
MORPH
........................................................................................................134
National Tropical Botanical Garden Fellowship for College Professors
....135
Courses/Workshops
Biology S-105 "Biodiversity of tropical plants."
.........................................136
Positions Available
Paleobotanist., East Tennessee State University
.........................................136
Systematic and Evolutionary Biology, University of Georgia
......................137
Orchid Taxonomist, Marie Selby Botanical Gardens
..................................137
Dean and Vice President for Science,International Plant Science Center New York Botanical Garden
....................137
Director of Research & Chair, Department of Botany, Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden, Claremont, California
......138
Other News
NEON Progress Report
.................................................................................................138
New Exhibition Showcases Research Projects by New York Botanical Garden Scientists.
...........................................139
Books Reviewed
............................................................................................................................140
BSA Contact Information.
............................................................................................................155
Books Received
.............................................................................................................................155
Botanical Society of America Logo Items
.....................................................................................156
Plant Science Bulletin 51(4) 2005
ISSN 0032-0919
Plant Science Bulletin
ISSN 0032-0919
Published quarterly by Botanical Society of America, Inc., 4475 Castleman Avenue,
St. Louis, MO 63166-0299. The yearly subscription rate of $15 is included in
the membership dues of the Botanical Society of America, Inc. Periodical postage
paid at St. Louis, MO and additional mailing office.
Address Editorial Matters (only) to:
Marsh Sundberg, Editor
Dept. Biol. Sci., Emporia State Univ.
1200 Commercial St.
Emporia, KS 66801-5057
Phone 620-341-5605
E-mail: psb@botany.org
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to:
Botanical Society of America
Business Office
P.O. Box 299
St. Louis, MO 63166-0299
E-mail: bsa-manager@botany.org
Editorial Committee for Volume 51
Andrew W. Douglas (2005)
Department of Biology
University of Mississippi
University, MS 38677
adouglas@olemiss.edu
Douglas W. Darnowski (2006)
Department of Biology
Indiana University Southeast
New Albany, IN 47150
ddarnowski2@ius.edu
Andrea D. Wolfe (2007)
Department of EEOB
1735 Neil Ave., OSU
Columbus, OH 43210-1293
wolfe.205@osu.edu
Samuel Hammer (2008)
College of General Studies
Boston University
Boston, MA 02215
cladonia@bu.edu
Joanne M. Sharpe (2009)
Coastal Maine Botanical Gardens
P.O. Box 234
Boothbay ME 04537
joannesharpe@email.com
This is the last issue of Plant Science Bulletin before we begin the Botanical
Society's Centennial Year. What better way is there to prepared for the celebration
than to highlight the career of one of our most distinguished former members,
especially if she happened to be President of the Botanical Society of America
during our 50th year? I originally invited Dr. Lee Kass to write a shorter piece
about Harriet Creighton to give us a sense her personality as well as her scholarship.
Lee, who is chairperson of the BSA Historical Section, has presented us with a
piece of her own scholarship that goes well beyond my original request. I am proud
to be affiliated with the organization to which Creighton was so dedicated. I'm
sure you'll feel the same way! -Editor
100th
Anniversary Series
HARRIET B. CREIGHTON: PROUD BOTANIST
Harriet Creighton (1909-2004) was the third woman elected to the presidency
(1956) and the first woman secretary (1950-54) of the Botanical Society
of America (BSA). Creighton's many contributions to the BSA and to botanical
education are often overshadowed by her most cited work, the first demonstration
of cytological and genetical crossing-over in Zea mays (McClintock
1931, Creighton and McClintock 1931, Coe and Kass 2005a). The investigation
was part of Creighton's dissertation research project (Creighton 1933) at
Cornell University (1929-1934), under the guidance of her collaborator,
Dr. Barbara McClintock, who had suggested the problem. Their study provided
additional confirmation of the chromosome theory of inheritance for which
Thomas Hunt Morgan would win a Nobel Prize in 1933.
While a graduate student in 1973, I was first introduced to Creighton
during the Thirteenth International Congress of Genetics in Berkeley, CA.
Years later, in the context of interviewing Creighton about her work with
McClintock, I experienced her outgoing and generous nature (Kass 1994, 1996).
In long, beautifully printed, hand-written letters, she carefully answered
my many questions about early investigations in maize cytogenetics, and
about students and faculty in Cornell's Departments of Botany and Plant
Breeding, including insights on policies and procedures for gaining academic
jobs and rank in the early 20th century (Kass 2001, Kass 2003, Kass et
al. 2005, Kass 2005). She also gave me her own cherished copies of
celebrated works by Lester W. Sharp (Fotheringham 1928) and Alan C. Fraser
(Emerson et al. 1935), members of her Ph.D. committee.
Creighton recalled that Margaret Clay Ferguson (1863-1951), her undergraduate
Professor of Cytology at Wellesley College, encouraged her to study at
Cornell University. Ferguson had received her B.S. (1899) and Ph.D. from
Cornell (Ferguson 1901), and was the first woman president of the BSA (1929).
Creighton returned to Wellesley as a member of their faculty, where she
enthusiastically continued Ferguson's commitment to the botanical sciences,
endeavored to expand her programs in botany, and encouraged the Department
and Trustees to name the Wellesley greenhouse complex in her honor (Creighton
1947).
Although she was pleased and proud to discuss McClintock's early contributions
to science, recognized much later by her 1983 Nobel Prize winning research,
Creighton denied that she had made much of a scientific contribution herself.
As early as 1938, Creighton is listed in American Men of Science
(Cattell and Cattell 1938:307).She was not starred, however, among the top
ranking 1,000 scientists in the United States, as were her mentors, Ferguson
(starred in Botany, 1910) and McClintock (starred in Botany, 1944) (Rossiter
1982:293). It was only after her death that I gained access to her
CV and Publications List, which were generouly provided by the Wellesley
College archives (WCA). Creighton's publications and early contributions
to maize
genetics may be found in issues of Proceedings of the National Academy
of Sciences (PNAS), Maize Genetics Cooperation News Letter,
Records of the Genetics Society of America, and citations to her
works appear in many books and journals, whose authors also acknowledge
her for sharing data.
Her major contributions to our field, however, are her behind-the-scenes
participation on many national science education committees for the BSA,
the American Institute of Biological Sciences (AIBS), and the National Science
Foundation's National Research Council (NSF/NRC) (Faculty File, WCA).
Much of her involvement on these committees has been described in the pages
of the Plant Science Bulletin (PSB1), of which
she was a founding member. Additionally, Creighton served on the PSB
editorial board (1955-1959), was acting editor (1956), and had graciously
accepted editorial responsibilities in May 1958, when founding editor Harry
J. Fuller took ill. She wrote articles encouraging innovation in teaching
(Creighton 1956, 1958), and in her retiring presidential address, she encouraged
her fellow botanists to be as proud as she was of their botanical roots,
and challenged them with the call "Botanists of the World, Unite! and Get
Going" (Creighton 1957).
Early Achievements, 1929-1940
The Cornell Years: Creighton was born in Delavan,
Illinois on June 29, 1909. At age 20 she graduated from Wellesley College
(A.B. 1929), and accepted an assistantship (1929-1932) in General Botany
with Loren C. Petry, Professor of Paleobotany in the Department of Botany,
College of Agriculture, at Cornell University. Creighton's mother accompanied
her to Ithaca, where Barbara McClintock took the young graduate student
under her wing (Figure 1). It was McClintock, Creighton told me, who suggested
that she pursue a Doctorate in Cytology with L.W. Sharp and to bypass the
Masters degree, which she had considered doing initially. McClintock, an
Instructor and Sharp's teaching assistant, introduced Creighton to Sharp
at his home, where he was recovering from a broken toe.
Creighton was familiar with Sharp's recently published textbook, Introduction
to Cytology (Sharp 1926), and expected to meet a stodgy grey-haired
professor. Instead, she was pleasantly surprised to find a young man with
a crew cut, who loved music and had a wonderful sense of humor. His hoax
of the woofen-poof bird, Eoörnis pterovelox gobiensis, published
the previous year under the pseudonym A. C. Fotheringham (1928), was the
talk of the department. She was present when Sharp read with disbelief
its review published in The Quarterly Review of Biology (Pearl 1930).
He truly believed that the reviewer had been taken-in, she recalled laughingly,
until he reached the end of the summary, where it was made clear that the
so called serious review was a spoof in itself.
Sharp was Vice-president of the BSA when Creighton arrived at Cornell
in 1929, and he was elected President the following year. L.H. Bailey,
Dean of the College of Agriculture, had been President in 1926, and Karl
M. Wiegand, Chair of the Department, would be elected President in 1938.
George F. Atkinson, first President of the BSA (1907), was a Cornellian,
and other Botany Department faculty members were affiliated and would become
officers of the Society (BSA 2005:234); most faculty members in the Plant
Breeding Department had also joined.
McClintock suggested Creighton's minor subject areas, Plant Physiology and
Genetics, and the Professors whom she should include on her committee, Otis
F. Curtis, a member of the Botany Department, and Alan C. Fraser, in the
Plant Breeding Department. In 1929, Creighton learned many new plant cytological
techniques from McClintock, and met Charles Burnham, a National Research
Council (NRC) Fellow who had arrived that summer at Cornell from Wisconsin
to work with Rollins A. Emerson, the head of the Plant Breeding Department.
They worked together in close quarters in Sharp's Cytology Laboratory in
Stone Hall, where Creighton shared a desk with future Nobel Laureate, George
W. Beadle (Creighton 1992, Burnham 1992, Kass and Bonneuil 2004).
Emerson and Beadle, his student, had initiated the Maize Genetics
Cooperation News Letter in April 1929 (Kass et al. 2005; Coe
and Kass 2005b), where students of maize genetics shared their unpublished
data. Cooperation among students was fostered in Sharp's laboratory and
encouraged by Emerson, who also established the Maize Genetics Cooperation
at Cornell (Kass et al. 2005). This cooperative spirit shaped Creighton's
view of joint efforts and ethical practice in science (Letter, Creighton
to Kass, 27 Feb. 1995; Kass 2001).
Emerson also encouraged faculty and graduate students in the Departments
of Botany and Plant Breeding to attend Synapsis Club meetings. Creighton
went regularly with her major professor and graduate student colleagues.
The club sponsored weekly dinners with speakers, held special social gatherings,
and organized a bowling league on which Creighton was a star performer
(Synapsis Club Records, Cornell University Archives). Creighton was quite
athletic. She played tennis regularly with her graduate student colleagues,
and was renowned for climbing the buildings at Cornell. When I asked her
about a story I had heard regarding McClintock climbing up the Plant Science
Building to get into her office when she had forgotten her key, Creighton
said emphatically that it was she who had climbed to the second floor of
the building, entered through the window, and unlocked the door. She added:
"That building was just meant to be climbed."
In their study of the cytological basis of crossing-over, Creighton used
a semisterile corn stock with a prominent knob at the tip of the short arm
of chromosome 9, and having a piece of chromosome 8 attached (a translocation).
Burnham had brought the stock with him from Wisconsin and generously shared
it with them (McClintock 1930, McClintock 1931, Creighton and McClintock
1931, Kass and Bonneuil 2004, Coe and Kass 2005a). McClintock had applied
Belling's chromosome squash technique to the anthers in this strain of corn,
and first clearly observed corn chromosomes at the pachytene stage (McClintock
1930, Kass 2003). Creighton took advantage of this new technique
and by April 1931, had limited data to support a claim for a correlation
of "genetical and cytological crossing over." Morgan, who had learned of
their results during a spring lecture tour at Cornell, encouraged them
to publish immediately (Coe and Kass 2005a, see also Keller 1983).
FIGURE 1. Barbara McClintock and Harriet Creighton at Cornell University,
June 1930 (reprinted with permission from Kass 2003, Genetics).
Creighton became Sharp's assistant in Cytology when McClintock left Cornell
to begin her NRC Fellowship at Missouri in June of 1931. They corresponded regularly
regarding their upcoming publications (McClintock 1931, Creighton and McClintock
1931), which were submitted by Emerson in July and published in the August PNAS
(Coe and Kass 2005a). Unfortunately, none of their letters about these critical
papers have been saved (Postcard, Creighton to Kass, 8 Dec. 1996), but Emerson's
correspondence is in the Cornell University Archives. Creighton granted permission
to reprint their article in a number of collected readings in Biology, and a
diagram from their paper was reproduced in many biology and genetics textbooks
(Coe and Kass 2005a; Faculty File, WCA).
At the 6th International Congress of Genetics, at Cornell in 1932, they collaboratively
presented evidence for 4-strand crossing over in corn (Creighton and McClintock
1932). Creighton continued to contribute unpublished data to the Maize Genetics
Cooperation News Letter, and published new findings on deficiencies on chromosome
9 of corn (Creighton 1934).
As a graduate student, Creighton was elected to the Women's Scientific
Fraternity, Sigma Delta Epsilon (Graduate Women in Science) in 1930.
Their motto was "United in Friendship through Science," and their goal
was to promote interest in science and to advance the participation and
recognition of women in science. The Alpha Chapter had been established
at Cornell in 1921, and Creighton later became an officer of the National
organization (Second Vice-president, 1948-49; First Vice-president 1949-50;
National President 1950) and also chaired their Research Awards Committee
(1968-1969). In 1931, she was elected to the Cornell Chapter of the honorary
scientific society, Sigma Xi, which had been founded at Cornell in
1886; and to Phi Kappa Phi, in 1932, whose mission is "To recognize
and promote academic excellence in all fields of higher education and to
engage the community of scholars in service to others."
Creighton completed her thesis in 1933 (Creighton 1933) and remained in the
Botany Department at Cornell as an Instructor of cytology and microtechnique
(1932-1934), until accepting a job at Connecticut College for Women (CCW) in
1934 (Cattell 1944:383; Letter, Creighton to P. Davies, 6 May 1993).
CCW Botanist, 1934-1940: Creighton was an Instructor in Botany
at CCW from 1934 to 1938. She was promoted to Assistant Professor in 1938 (Barnhart
1965:394), on the basis of years of service both at Cornell and CCW. She explained
that the rules for promotion and tenure were different at that time (Letter,
Creighton to Kass 27 Feb. 1995), and I subsequently learned that not all academic
institutions followed AAUP guidelines for tenure and promotion, which were in
flux during this era (Kass 2003, Kass 2005).
With McClintock, she published (1935) a corroboration of their investigations
of cytological crossing over, and gave papers at meetings of the Genetics Society
of America (see their Records for abstracts of her papers). Creighton
worked collaboratively with G.S. Avery, P.R. Burkholder, and others at Connecticut
College, on a translation and revision of Peter Boysen-Jensen's (1883-1959)
Growth Hormones in Plants, which was expanded to include 188 new contributions
to the literature and 40 additional illustrations (Avery et al. 1936).
With Avery, Burkholder, and others at Connecticut College, she also conducted
a series of plant physiology experiments that were mainly published in the American
Journal of Botany (AJB ) between 1936 and 1941. Creighton
called these her ABC papers, because the 11 papers published with Avery, Burkholder,
and others had the authors' names listed in alphabetical order (at Avery's insistence,
she recalled).
Contributions 1940-1974
Wellesley College, Associate Professor to Department Chair:
Creighton jumped at the chance to return to her alma mater as a member
of their faculty. In 1940, she was appointed Associate Professor of Botany
at Wellesley, elected a Fellow of the AAAS, and reviewed manuscripts for
the AJB. In addition to teaching, she continued to conduct research
on corn, and in 1941, she was invited to spend the summer at Cold Spring
Harbor with McClintock and other guest investigators who studied plant genetics
(Kass 2005).
Soon after the U.S. entered World War II, Mildred McAfee, President of Wellesley
College, recruited Creighton for the WAVES (Women Accepted for Volunteer Emergency
Service). According to Naval history (
http://www.history.navy.mil ), McAfee was sworn in as a Naval Reserve
Lieutenant Commander, the first female commissioned officer in the U.S. Navy
history, and the first Director of the WAVES, the women's branch of the Navy.
The Navy had accepted a large number of enlisted women and needed Commissioned
Officers to supervise them. The WAVES performed previously atypical duties such
as communications, intelligence, science and technology. Creighton was granted
a leave of absence for war service (1943-May 1946) and rose to the final rank
of Lieutenant Commander.
Creighton loved to travel. At the conclusion of the war, she and Gertrude
Dever, a friend she had met in the WAVES, embarked on a cross-country adventure
in an old multi-colored jalopy, making stops along the way in New Orleans
and Mexico (Wellesley Club News 2005). Upon returning to Wellesley, she
was appointed Chair of her Department. After recommending that the Wellesley
Greenhouses be named for Ferguson, she followed in the footsteps of her
mentor, and enthusiastically supported Wellesley's Arboretum, Botanic Gardens
and The Ferguson Greenhouses as "premier educational sites" and was committed
to maintaining them as such (Biographical File, WCA). In 1946, she initiated
Garden Day, where local garden clubs were invited to Wellesley to view the
greenhouse and gardens. This eventually led to the founding of the Wellesley
College Friends of Horticulture (WCFH) in 1982, whose members raised funds
for the renovation of the Ferguson Greenhouses, completed ten years later.
The Harriet B. Creighton Room at the Visitor Center of the Margaret C.
Ferguson Greenhouses was dedicated to honor her years of service to the Botany
Department and her ongoing support for the College's Botanic Gardens. It
was in this room where I first interviewed Creighton, and photographed her
outside of the building (Figures 2 & 3).
While carrying a full teaching load and guiding the department at Wellesley,
she also served as Secretary of the BSA Teaching Section (1948-1951), was a
member of the AAAS Council (1949-1951), and was elected Secretary of the BSA
in 1950. The latter office had previously been filled by Petry and A. J. Eames,
her former Cornell teachers, and Avery and Burkholder, former colleagues at
Connecticut College (BSA 2005:235).
She was promoted to Professor of Botany in 1952. That year she was a
Fulbright Lecturer in Genetics and Plant Physiology (with 4 months of research),
at the University of Western Australia, Perth, and at Adelaide University,
which fulfilled her desire for travel abroad. This experience was so rewarding
that seven years later she again went abroad as a Fulbright Lecturer in
Genetics (with 3 months for research) at the National University of Cuzco,
Peru.
In 1955, Creighton was named the Ruby F.H. Farwell Professor of Botany,
in acknowledgement of her outstanding success at Wellesley. In that year
she was also elected Vice-president of the BSA, served on the PSB
editorial board (through 1959) and participated (through 1958) in an NSF
Panel for the selection of Predoctoral Fellows. She also served as a Member-at
Large for the 14th -16th (1955-1957) Symposium of the Society for Developmental
Biology.
As BSA President, Creighton had the honor of presenting Certificates of Merit
to 50 distinguished scientists for their contributions to botany, at the 50th
anniversary Golden Jubilee Merit Citations award banquet, held on August 29,
1956, at the University of Connecticut, Storrs (PSB , Oct. 1956, pgs.1-2).
Among those first honored were George W. Beadle, her graduate school colleague;
Edgar Anderson, with whom she had cooperated at Cold Spring Harbor in the summer
of 1941; and nine BSA past Presidents, including Anderson, and Katherine Esau,
the second woman elected President of the society. At that time, the society
also announced its plan to present certificates to additional botanists in succeeding
years.
The following year, at the BSA annual banquet, held at Stanford University,
Creighton's former mentor, Barbara McClintock, received a Certificate of Merit,
as a pioneer in the use of chromosomal aberrations for the purpose of genome
analysis, important contributions to the theory of gene structure, and "world
leader in the broad field of cytogenetics" (PSB, Jan. 1958, pp.5-6).
Creighton must have felt proud of McClintock, and the other plant geneticists
so honored that night, as she delivered the retiring past-President's address
(Creighton 1957). "If we would put together all the findings of all kinds of
botanist, we would be proud enough of the results that we would not be ashamed
of being called botanist," she assured her audience. Some investigators, she
emphasized, call themselves "pure botanists," while others work on applied problems,
"yet all study plants and are, therefore, botanists." But some, she noted, do
not want to be called a "botanist." She suggested that we use the word botany
and make clear that botany includes the study of all plants, and "call ourselves
botanists with some pride in our voices. ... We have to change the climate of
opinion concerning botany," she said. "We have to sell ourselves, and then the
educated and intelligent public, that we are students of plants and that plants
are important in the modern world. ... Botanists of the World, Unite!" she urged,
then added, "and Get Going!"
Professor Creighton's commitment to Botanical Education: "Creighton
was an amazing teacher," wrote one of her former students in a note appearing
in the WCFH Spring 2004 News, devoted to her memory. Clearly she was
dedicated to her profession, which is demonstrated by her leadership in the
BSA and her active participation on national committees for botanical education.
As a member of the Society's Education Committee, she supported their proposal
to the National Science Foundation (NSF) for a Summer Institute for Botany teachers
from small colleges to be held at Cornell in 1956. NSF notified President Creighton
in December 1955, of the $31,400 Award for their first supported Summer Institute
for college teachers. Institute Director H.P. Banks (Cornell University), Past
President Ralph Wetmore (1953; Harvard University), and Creighton made the stipend
awards to 50 college teachers to acquaint them with current work in the field
(PSB, Oct. 1956, p.12).
FIGURE 2. Harriet Creighton outside the Margaret C. Ferguson Greenhouses,
Wellesley College, 1994 (Photograph by author).
Creighton continued serving on NSF Panels for Summer Institutes for College
and High School Teachers of Biology through 1959. She was one of the outstanding
lecturers who participated in the NSF-supported Summer Institute for College
Botany Teachers, sponsored by the BSA, and sustained at Indiana University
in 1959 (PSB, Dec. 1958, p. 3). Concurrently, she was a member of
the NSF Committee on Teaching Biology (1956-1957), and was invited to join
the AIBS Committee on Education and Professional Recruitment's Steering
Committee (1956-1966) for the Secondary School Film Series (PSB
, April 1959, pp. 1-3), in which she played a "teacher" in several individual
films (Faculty File, WCA). While editor of PSB, Creighton (1958)
encouraged writers and publishers of Botany and Biology text books to "experiment
with texts that are really a third arm of a course, the first two being
the teacher and the organisms studied in the field and laboratory."
Creighton was secretary (1960-1963) of Section G (Botanical Sciences)
of the AAAS, and concurrently chaired the BSA's Committee on Education for
two years (1960-1962). The Committee studied the Role of Botany in America,
and she helped to formulate their recommendations concerning High School
Biology Courses, Introductory Courses in Biology, and the "Facts and Principles
that should be taught" (PSB, March 1958, pp. 1-2). They sent an
open invitation to BSA members requesting that they prepare a series of articles
on botanical subjects, particularly for teachers of biology in secondary
schools and colleges, for publication in Turtox News. Chair Creighton
was responsible for editing all manuscripts contributed by members of the
society (PSB, May 1961, p 8).
As part of her responsibilities for the BSA Education Committee, Creighton
was a botanical consultant (1961-1969) to A. J. Nystrom and Co. (Chicago),
who produced 12 teaching charts (with transparencies for overhead projection)
and 8 models of plant structure, which she had designed (Faculty File,
WCA; PSB, Dec. 1963, p4). They anonymously published eight booklets
(prepared by Creighton between 1963 through 1968), each comparable to a
short chapter of a textbook, to accompany each of the botanical teaching
models (Faculty File, WCA).
Rossiter (1995:304) has documented the under-recognition of women scientists,
who in the 1950 and 1960s were "practically invisible to the public, to
other scientists, and to each other." Creighton's early scientific achievements
are well recorded; and her behind-the-scenes efforts towards academic and
public education were recognized by her peers, if one considers it an honor
to chair committees and to be elected a society officer. These contributions,
however, were probably mostly invisible to the public.
Research interests and further responsibilities: Along with her
teaching and committee responsibilities, Creighton pursued research on
the genetics of Petunia flowers, which she presented independently,
and with students, at the annual meetings of the Genetics Society of America
(GSA) in the 1940s. Later, she became interested in the horticultural aspects
of Begonia. Those studies were presented at the BSA, and published
in The Begonian during the 1960 and 1970s. To keep current in her
field, she spent a sabbatical year in the Botany Department at the University
of California, Berkeley (Sept.-Dec. 1966) and at the Cell Research Institute
of the University of Texas in Austin (Jan-June 1967).
In the early 1960s, she was President of the Wellesley Chapter of the
Society of Sigma Xi. She regularly attended annual meetings of the
BSA and the GSA, and when possible, drove to Long Island, NY, for the Cold
Spring Harbor Symposium. She traveled to India as a consultant for NSF (1968,
1969) and also accepted committee assignments from the GSA. While an editorial
board member (1969-1975) of the Journal of College Science Teaching
, she reviewed more than 30 manuscripts beginning with Volume 1. Additionally,
she refereed book manuscripts and journal articles, and published many book
reviews.
A year before retirement, she joined the Historical Section of the BSA
(1973) and was its representative to the Executive Committee. In keeping
with her principles, she also offered a class on Basic Botany and Horticulture
for the Massachusetts Horticultural Society, and gave a National Science
Teachers Association workshop for high school teachers on the use of plants
for experiments in their classes. Her energy seemed boundless.
The Retirement Years 1974-2004, and beyond
Honors and Recognition: Creighton kept busy after her 1974 retirement
as Ruby F.H. Farwell Professor Emerita. Possessing exceptional institutional
memory, she was consulted on all aspects of Wellesley College life; wrote
the chapter on "The Grounds" for the centennial volume Wellesley College
1875-1975, A Century of Women; and as a member of the Wellesley Campus
Master Plan Committee (1998), recalled each transformation made since her
first day on campus in 1925 (Biographical Files, WCA). The Massachusetts
Horticultural Society honored her with the Large Gold Medal of their society
in 1985, for her botanical expertise and "horticultural concern in the
community." Public recognition had been achieved at last. In 1994, The
Wellesley College Alumnae Association recognized her with the Syrina Stackpole
Award for "dedicated service and exceptional commitment to Wellesley College."
Posthumous honors: Creighton died at age 94, on January 9, 2004
(The Wellesley Townsman, 22 Jan. 2004, p. 34). That year, the Wellesley
College Botanical Greenhouse Fund, established by Creighton in 1955 with
an initial modest gift, was renamed the Harriet Creighton Greenhouse Fund
for continued support of the Margaret Clay Ferguson Greenhouses.
Creighton lived a long, happy, and successful life. Her legacy of
contributions to Botany in the 20th century has persisted and sustained the
broad field of Plant Biology. Let us dedicate this issue of the Plant
Science Bulletin in honor of Harriet Baldwin Creighton to celebrate
with pride the Golden Jubilee Anniversary of the publication she co-founded
50 years ago.
FIGURE 3. Harriet Creighton and Lee Kass, Wellesley College, 1994 (Photograph
by Beverly Rathcke).
Acknowledgments
I thank the staff of the Wellesley College Archives and the L.H. Bailey
Hortorium Library for providing valuable resources for this study; W.B.
Provine and C. Uhl for use of their libraries; Shawn Krosnick for sharing
files on M.C. Ferguson; Faculty and Staff of the Department of Plant Biology,
Cornell University, for logistical support, especially Sherry Vance for
preparing the images; I am grateful to E.H. Coe, R.E. Dirig, R.E. Hunt,
R.P. Murphy C. Uhl and R. Whalen, for helpful suggestions on revising the
manuscript; and special appreciation to BSA Past President Judy Jernstedt
for suggesting the topic.
- Lee Kass
Literature Cited Cattell, J.M. and J. Cattell (eds.). 1938. American Men of Science,
a Biographical Directory, 6th Ed. The Science Press, Lancaster, PA.
Cattell, J. (ed.). 1944. American Men of Science, a Biographical Directory
, 7th Ed. The Science Press, Lancaster, PA.
Barnhart, J.H. 1965. Biographical Notes Upon Botanists. Vol.
1-3. G.K. Hall and Co. Boston, MA.
Botanical Society of America (BSA). 2005. Membership Directory and
Handbook, 2005. Saint Louis, MO.
Burnham, C. 1992. Barbara McClintock: Reminiscences, pp. 19-24 in
N. Fedoroff and D. Botstein (eds.) The Dynamic Genome: Barbara McClintock's
Ideas in the Century of Genetics. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press,
Plainview, New York.
Avery, G.S. Jr., and P.B. Burkholder, in collaboration with H.B. Creighton
and B.A Scheer. 1936. Translation and revision of Peter Boysen-Jensen's
(1883-1959) Growth Hormones in Plants. McGraw-Hill Book Company,
Inc, New York.
Coe, E. and L.B. Kass. 2005a. Proof of physical exchange of genes on
the chromosomes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102(19): 6641-6656.
_____ and _____. 2005b. Maize Genetics Cooperation News Letter Files:
Expanded chronological list of materials and related cooperation. Maize
Genetics Cooperation Newsletter 79: 72-76.
Creighton, H.B. 1933. A cytogenetic study of crossing-over in Zea mays.
Ph.D. Thesis. Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
_____. 1934. Three cases of deficiency in Chromosome 9 of Zea mays.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 20:111-115.
_____. 1947. The Margaret C. Ferguson Greenhouses. Wellesley Alumni
Magazine Vol. XXI. Feb. 1947.
_____. 1956. Future text book writers please note. Plant Science
Bulletin 2(3):11.
_____. 1957. Botanists of the world unite — and Get Going. Plant
Science Bulletin 3(3):1-4.
_____. 1958. One teacher's questions about General Biology and General
Botany textbooks. Plant Science Bulletin. 4(4):1-3.
_____. 1992. Recollections of Barbara McClintock's Cornell Years, pp.
14-18 in N. Fedoroff and D. Botstein (eds.) The Dynamic Genome: Barbara
McClintock's Ideas in the Century of Genetics Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Press, Plainview, NY.
_____ and B. McClintock. 1931. A correlation of cytological and genetical
crossing-over in Zea mays. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 17:483-491.
_____ and _____. 1932. Cytological Evidence for 4-strand crossing over
in Zea mays. Proc. VI International Congress of Genetics
Vol. II: 392.
_____ and _____. 1935. A corroboration of cytological and genetical crossing-over
in Zea mays. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 21:148-150.
Emerson, R.A., G.W. Beadle, and A.C. Fraser. 1935. A summary of linkage
studies in maize. Cornell Univ. Agric. Exp. Station Memoir 180:1-83.
Fotheringham, A.C. [L.W. Sharp and Cuthbert V. Fraser]. 1928. Eoörnis
pterovelox gobiensis. The Buighleigh Press, London.
Ferguson, M.C. 1901. On the development of the pollen tube and the
division of the generative nucleus in certain species of pine. Ph.D.
Thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York (reprinted from Annals of
Botany, Vol. XV no. LVIII, June 1901).
Kass, L.B. 1994. Interview with Harriet B. Creighton at Wellesley College,
23 August 1994.
_____. 1997. Tape-recorded interview with Harriet B. Creighton at Wellesley
College, 17 August 1996.
_____. 2001. Ethics in science: preparing students for their career.
Plant Science Bulletin 47(2, Summer):42-48.
_____. 2003. Records and recollections: A new look at Barbara McClintock,
Nobel Prize-Winning geneticist. Genetics 164(August):1251-1260.
_____. 2005. Missouri compromise: tenure or freedom. New evidence clarifies
why Barbara McClintock left academe. Maize Genetics Cooperation Newsletter 79:52-71.
_____. and C. Bonneuil. 2004. Mapping and seeing: Barbara McClintock
and the linking of genetics and cytology in maize genetics, 1928-1935.
Chap. 5, pp. 91-118, In Hans-Jörg Rheinberger and Jean-Paul Gaudilliere
(eds.), Classical Genetic Research and its Legacy: The Mapping Cultures
of 20th Century Genetics. London: Routledge.
_____, _____ and E.H. Coe. 2005. Cornfests, cornfabs and cooperation:
The origins and beginnings of the Maize Genetics Cooperation News Letter.
Genetics 169 (April): 1787-1797.
Keller, E.F. 1983. A Feeling for the Organism. The Life and Work
of Barbara McClintock. W. H. Freeman and Co. San Francisco, CA.
McClintock, B. 1930. A cytological demonstration of the location of an
interchange between two non-homologous chromosomes of Zea mays.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 16:791-796.
_____. 1931. The order of the genes C, Sh, and Wx in Zea mays
with reference to a cytologically known point in the chromosome. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 17:485-491.
Pearl, R. 1930. Review of Eoörnis pterovelox gobiensis. Quarterly
Review of Biology 5:112-113.
Rossiter, M.W. 1982. Women Scientists in America: Struggles and Strategies
to 1940. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD.
_____. 1995. Women Scientists in America: Before Affirmative Action
1940-1972. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD.
Sharp, L.W. 1926. Introduction to Cytology, 2nd edition. McGraw-Hill
Book Co, Inc. New York.
Wellesley College Archives (WCA). 2005. H.B. Creighton, Biographical
Files and Faculty File. Wellesley MA 02101.
Wellesley Club News. 2005. The College Club gets a gift of a lift.
Wellesley College Club News. Summer 2005. Wellesley College, Wellesley,
MA, http://www.wellesley.edu/Collegeclub/summer05.pdf,
accessed 5 October 2005.
Lee B. Kass is Visiting Professor in the L. H. Bailey Hortorium, Department
of Plant Biology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY,
lbk7@cornell.edu,
where she is preparing an intellectual biography of Barbara McClintock.
She is Chair of the Historical Section of the BSA, and a member of the
Centennial Committee. The second edition of her Illustrated Guide to
Common Plants of San Salvador Island, Bahamas has recently been published
by the Gerace Research Center, San Salvador Island, Bahamas.
1Full citations listed only for feature articles published
in the Plant Science Bulletin; announcements found therein are cited within
parentheses.
News from the Society
From the Annual Meeting
The Power of Plants: Building Collaborations
among Educational Institutions, Botanical Gardens and Communities.
(Banquet speech given by Ed Schneider, President-elect, at the 99th meeting
of the Botanical Society of America, August 17, 2005, Austin, TX).
The theme for the 99th meeting of the Botanical Society of America "Learning
From Plants" inspired the title of my presentation. The "Power of Plants"
presents several interwoven themes: career development from student to
faculty member; tribute to those who fostered and inspired us through our
professional growth; and an action plan for the future of the Botanical
Society of America and the value added benefits of expanding partnerships
and collaborations among agencies and organizations that have at the core
of their missions improved understanding and promotion of plants. These
interwoven themes have a common overarching theme, the power of plants, since
plants have inspired and influenced the course of our careers and all aspects
of human activity.
As students, we may recall those moments when we first developed an interest
in the botanical world. For me, it began when I was an undergraduate and
asked by a faculty member to consider becoming a teaching assistant for
a course in introductory botany. That was the hook. Graduate school soon
followed with thesis work on the amazing Amazon water lily, Victoria.
Who could not be inspired by those remarkably large, 6'- 8' diameter leaves.
I recall clearly the hot day in early August in Tempe, AZ (1974) when
I attended my first Botanical Society of America annual meeting to make
a scientific presentation on findings about that remarkable plant. Then
began the quest to secure the first faculty position, followed by the journey
toward tenure, promotion, and assuming the same leadership role in fostering
students as faculty members had done for me years earlier.
During my career I felt a particular motivation to study hydrophytes,
especially waterlilies. Adaptations to the aquatic life are fascinating.
The molecular investigations leading to added confirmation of the long held
hypothesis that waterlilies are among the basal-most flowering plants also
helped to secure funding and a widening interest in the Nymphaeaceae.
As botanists, we understand the importance of plants for their life sustaining
photosynthetic process. Within our classrooms and laboratories we emphasize
to hundreds of thousands of students each year, the oxygen generation role
of autotrophs, and the carbohydrate (food) production that sustains life
through food chains. We marvel at the fact that 74% of the human population
is sustained by less than ten crop species. The role of plants in providing
fuels, shelter, medicines and drugs, and a vast variety of products used
each day in our lives makes me pause and ask _ while students may find this
intriguing and understandable, can we do more to excite and involve a larger
audience that will stand and with a unified voice, pronounce that plants
are important, they need more study, and work in concert to raise the conscientiousness
of all to the importance of plants.
It is not surprising that gardening is the number one past time in the
United States. Aside from the therapeutic benefits, we bask in the beauty
of plants, marvel at their form and growth as we harvest homegrown fruits
and vegetables. Eco-tourism has also become popular over the past decade
or two, and understandably, since natural landscapes offer immense beauty
and inspiration.
In contrast to the natural landscape, the built landscape such as found in
botanical gardens offers a means, through inspiring, aesthetically developed
displays, conservation, research, and a broad spectrum of educational programming,
to an end _ to promote an enhanced understanding of the botanical world
and the importance of plants. Botanic gardens like other cultural organizations
in our communities are places that enrich lives; they are places of inspiration,
places to refresh the soul, places of beauty and tranquility, and places
to commune with and better understand our place in nature. This enrichment
process educates the visitor's mind, wins their hearts, and in doing so
leads to deeper levels of involvement, higher levels of ownership, and ultimately,
to improved philanthropy. If this process is cultivated well, the 200 million
visitors to U.S. botanic gardens each year represent more informed voters
about our environment and the importance of plants. Just as the Botanical
Society of America (BSA) has fostered interactions with educational organizations,
so, too, should BSA foster partnerships and collaboration with botanical
gardens. The advantages are clear, the linkage is natural. This is why
BSA selected the Missouri Botanic Garden as a partner and host. Botanic
gardens, like educational organizations, have at their core many similar
and overlapping programs. Botanic gardens are institutions that offer more
than just inspiring displays. They hold vast collections of living plants.
It is estimated that over 6 million living plants are held in the accessioned
collections of botanical gardens world-wide. These in situ and
ex situ collections offer rich collections for taxonomic and systematic
research conducted by faculty and students. Botanical gardens also hold enormous
herbaria collections, estimated to be over 50 million sheets, not to mention
outstanding botanical and horticultural library collections.
Another plant focused non-profit that is housed in partnership and collaboration
with the Missouri Botanic Garden, which BSA could build a partnership with
is The Center for Plant Conservation (CPC). The mission of CPC is to develop
a coordinated response for both ex situ and in situ conservation
of the American flora. Through a consortium of over 30 selected botanical
gardens, CPC maintains a National Collection of the most rare and endangered
plant species (610 species). CPC also has developed an Access database
with information on over 8,000 species and tracks accessions of over 13
million seed. The charter of CPC is also to: strengthen relationships and
scientific standards between all agencies involved in plant conservation
and research; integrate c onservation efforts without duplication; and to
offer public education and public relations programs to inform both the
scientific community and the general public. The increasing number of
contributed papers and abstracts presented each year at the annual BSA conference
that have conservation related themes is exciting. It may well be time
to establish a Conservation Section or offer thematically related papers
to be group into common sessions. Conservation is a cornerstone to most
botanical garden programming. Over 1 billion seeds have been banked in
gardens and of the 400,000 different species of plants, of which over 75,000
species are under threat - botanic gardens provide safe haven for over
10,000 of the world's most threatened plants. Botanic gardens have the
expertise to propagate and save rare species and are currently building
capacity to assess genetic variation in threatened populations. It is clear,
therefore, that continued collaboration and partnerships must be established
and strengthened among BSA, botanical gardens, and CPC, and that through
these partnerships all stakeholders become unified in their collective voices.
So, what can we do to strengthen the future of the Botanical Society
of America and its important mission? I offer the following action items:
build more partnerships and collaborations - and through our partnerships,
increase our voting constituencies if we wish to influence public attitudes
toward the environment and the botanical world; share what we know and
our discoveries more rapidly in digital format to make information more
accessible; tell our stories and articulate our positions widely to the
public and to policymakers, and grow in technical excellence, financial
capacity, and staff capacity in the home office. To varying degrees each
of these actions has begun, but much work lies ahead. Although there is
considerable work to be undertaken, we must take pause to have fun on this
journey because plants are an enjoyment. Remember, be an active advocate
for plants and the botanical world, be active in the Botanical Society of
America, and foster a growing relationship with your local botanical garden
and plant related organizations.
Educational Forum Keynote
Is it cool to know and do science? Can we create a Scientific Temper?
Linking Scientists, College Faculty, K-12 Teachers and their Students in Collaborative
Research.
Barbara Schulz
The National Academies, Teacher Advisory Council, Center for Education
Barbara Shulz is currently a Teacher Leader with the National Academy
in the Center for Education. She taught AP Biology and other science courses
in public and private schools for 35 years and is an active leader in science
education innovation. She has extensive experience linking scientists with
K-12 educators and developing authentic research opportunities for students
and teachers.
Ms. Schulz enumerated several challenges facing science and science education
including the need to increase inquiry science in K-12 classrooms, to connect
teachers with research and the scientists who conduct research, to increase
the number of students who will pursue careers in science, to increase student
motivation to learn, and finally, to help scientists share their research
with the public. She proposed that a shortage of science, mathematics and
engineering graduates is developing and could become a serious problem.
The number of United States students pursuing a career in science is decreasing,
while the demand for science and math graduates is increasing. Currently
46% of our science, mathematics and engineering students are from other countries.
Student interest in science starts decreasing in 7th grade,
and low percentages of students pursue careers in science, mathematics and
engineering. Clearly science teaching, as currently practiced in most schools
in the United States, is not encouraging students to pursue careers in science.
Ideas about how science would be best taught have been considered for
some time. The Committee of 10 in 1897 proposed that science classes should
not focus on memorization, but on acquisition of knowledge and intellectual
growth based on observation of nature, and that 60% of the class should
be used for the lab component (National Education Association 1903). Recently
published National Science Education Standards (National Research Council,
1996) stressed that science is an active process with inquiry into student-generated
questions at its center. The report asserts that supplementing this approach
with teaching and assessment strategies that develop a well-grounded understanding
of science will encourage students to continue investigating scientific
issues and become lifelong members of the scientific community.
The ways we teach science can also be informed by recent advances in
cognitive research. In 2005, the National Research Council published a
summary of current research and stressed that effective teaching needs to
start with what students think they already know. The report also stated
that teachers need to be at the forefront of deciding what is taught, why
it is taught, and what successful mastery of the topics looks like. Students
need to be encouraged to understand how they are learning and develop metacognitive
skills. To reach these goals requires an increase in inquiry science, which
means that teachers need to be comfortable with doing science and teaching
their students how to do science. A 2000 survey of biology teachers indicated
that teachers are not prepared to engage students in the practice of science
in any substantial way (Horizon Research, Inc., 2002).
Once teachers and scientists understand that they have common or mutually
beneficial goals, possibilities for collaboration become obvious. In fact,
there are many similarities between scientists and teachers. Both are passionate
about their work, and love analytical thinking. They both suffer from
public distrust to some degree yet depend on public funding to continue
their work. However, while scientists and academics tend to be critical,
K-12 teachers are more likely to take a nurturing approach toward students.
Scientists benefit from flexible schedules, have relatively high levels
of resources in comparison to K-12 schools, and are judged on their own
work. K-12 teachers are faced with rigid schedules, have few resources,
and are judged not by their own work, but by their students' achievements.
Comparing scientists and teachers as expert learners with students who are
novice learners is also informative. Most scientists and teachers are
unfamiliar with computer games and may have limited computer skills. Students
on the other hand, are well-versed in the use of computers and adapt readily
to new technology. Students need to develop a base of knowledge, develop
analytical skills, and the ability to learn in depth. They need to help
developing a structure for, or ways to organize, new knowledge. Connecting
scientists, teachers, and students via the internet may be a very productive
approach to engage students in doing science and create a collaborative
community involving students, teachers, and scientists.
A new initiative of the Botanical Society is the Scientific Inquiry through
Plants (Sip3)
project. This web-based inquiry science project links scientists, teachers,
and students from around the country. Teachers design their own inquiry-based
curriculum using the theme "The Wonder of Seeds". As students develop research
questions, hypotheses, and experimental designs, they post them to the internet.
Each team of students is mentored, via the internet, by a scientist. A pilot
of this innovative project was completed in the Spring of 2005 with very encouraging
results. Students from middle school to college appreciated that experts would
spend time helping with their projects. Teachers felt that students were more
motivated. The enthusiasm of novice learners was infectious for both teachers
and scientists.
Ms. Shulz concluded that programs such as Sip3 can meet the need
for inquiry learning in science classrooms. While students may not be strongly
interested in science, we can take advantage of their inclination to use
the internet to engage them in the process of doing science. Furthermore,
teachers who have weak botanical backgrounds, are encouraged to incorporate
plant-based activities in their classrooms, knowing that there are experts
who will mentor the student projects. Students who are doing science and
have access to experts, are much more likely to continue on in the sciences
which will help meet critical needs for scientists in the future. As the
Sip3 project develops additional components, scientists will have a venue
to communicate their love of science with the students, including their
own research topics. In this situation, everyone can win.
-summary contributed by Beverley Brown
References Cited Horizon Research, Inc., 2002. National survey of science and mathematics
education. Available at www.horizon-research.com
.
National Education Association. 1903. Report of the Committee on
Secondary School Studies.
National Research Council. 1996. National Science Education Standards,
National Academies Press, Washington, D.C. Available on-line at
http://books.nap.edu/books/0309053269/html/R1.html .
Donovan, M.S. and J.D. Branford, eds. 2005. How students learn.
History, mathematics and science in the classroom. National Academies
Press, Washington, D.C. Available on-line at
http://www.nap.edu/books/0309074339/html/ .
Summary of Scientific Meeting Keynote speaker:
Dr. José Sarukhán, Professor, Instituto de Ecología. National
Autonomous University of Mexico
Returning biodiversity knowledge and information to society: the case
of Mexico
Issues of biodiversity are not readily understood outside scientific circles
and the public has not strongly grasped the importance of preserving significant
areas of biodiversity. Dr. Sarukhán discussed a well-established
program in Mexico that makes information on biodiversity available to the
public (CONABIO: www.conabio.gob.mx). This
information can be used by scientists, policy makers, and members of the
general public. Developing databases of herbarium specimens and augmenting
collections so that they are representative of the flora and fauna in a
given area is imperative if this information is to be useful for both scientists
and the public. Easy access to information raises the possibility of linking
research to societal needs, rather than reserving access to information
for only a few botanists. There are many projects which are now possible
and in fact, proving very useful to decision makers in Mexico using the
information and analysis tools available through CONABIO. Human health
programs are using insect data to model insect distribution and target areas
that are high risk for specific insect-transmitted diseases. The data base
has been used to determine where commercially-grown genetically engineered
cotton could be introduced, making sure that introductions were well away
from naturally occurring Gossypium populations. CONABIO is also
used to track and report forest fires and is current within 12 hours which
increases the efficiency of fire fighting efforts. The database has been
used to draft legislation and study invasive species.
Since public funds are often the primary source of funding for herbaria
and scientific work research in general, there is an obligation on the part
of scientists to make this information available for use beyond botanists
conducting research. We need to continue to make herbaria specimens available
on-line. In the last 6 years there has been a 25% growth in the number
of specimens in herbaria, but only 5% of the specimens are electronically
catalogued. There is a need to continue developing access to information
in Mexico, as well as sharing information between Mexico and the United
States. We face the challenge of educating the public with regard to the
importance of biodiversity. If we can educate the public, we will not
face the challenge of educating decision makers alone. Once the public
is informed and truly understand the situation, they will work to inform
decision makers.
-summary contributed by Beverley Brown
Dear Botanical Society of America Members and Plant
Science Bulletin Readers
On behalf of the Botanical Society of America, and the BSA staff, I'd like
to wish you all a very happy and safe holiday season. We've enjoyed serving
you throughout a busy and productive 2005.
As a staff team, we are extremely excited to be celebrating the Botanical Society
of America's first 100 years. Celebrations will culminate at the Botany 2006
Conference in Chico, California. Please mark Botany 2006, July 28-August 3,
in your calendar. We look forward to seeing you all in Chico (make sure you
sign up for the centennial BSA banquet). "Looking to the Future - Conserving
the Past" will be a memorable conference and botanical gathering -
a once in a lifetime event. The Society will bring together, and honor, long-time
members and some of the most notable contributions to the plant sciences over
the past half-century. Follow developments at www.botany.org
.
BSA members, we will also keep you current through the monthly e-newsletter.
For us to keep in touch please check and, if need be, update your email
address (and other details) on the BSA database at
www.botany.org. Let us know if we can assist you in bringing your
details up-to-date. If you do not receive the monthly email newsletter,
please check with your systems operator and make sure it is not getting
thrown out as spam. You can also find a full list of BSA news and announcements
at .www.botany.org
BSA members who have yet to renew their 2006 membership, please go to
and renew online, or complete and send in the renewal form we mailed out
in the fall.
Plant Science Bulletin readers who wish to become BSA members, please
go to www.botany.org
. We'd be pleased to have you join us.
Again, have a great holiday season!
Sincerely, Bill Dahl
Botanical Society of America's Statement on Evolution
The Botanical Society of America exists to promote botany, the field
of basic science dealing with the study and inquiry into the form, function,
diversity, reproduction, evolution, and uses of plants and their interactions
within the biosphere. Our membership largely consist of professional scientists,
scholars, and educators from across the United States and Canada, and from
over 50 other countries. Most of us call ourselves botanists, plant biologists,
or plant scientists, and members of our profession teach and learn about
botanical organisms using well established principles and practices of
science. As such, we were asked by the National Center for Science Education
(NCSE) if we could provide a statement outlining our view on evolution.
On July 27,2003 at the 2003 Annual General Meeting the BSA Council approved
the statement to follow for use by the NCSE. For the Complete statement
see the Botanical Society website:
http://www.botany.org/newsite/announcements/evolution.php
Intelligent Design: It's Not Even Wrong
By Congressman (and Physicist) Rush Holt
As a research scientist and a member of the House Education Committee, I was
appalled when President Bush signaled his support for the teaching of "intelligent
design" alongside evolution in public K-12 science classes. Though I respect
and consistently protect the rights of persons of faith and the curricula of
religious schools, public school science classes are not the place to teach
concepts that cannot be backed up by evidence and tested experimentally. For
complete blog see
http://www.tpmcafe.com/story/2005/9/8/183216/1039
Centennial Medallion
The Centennial Meeting of BSA will be held at Chico State University,
California, 28 July -3 August 2006. Hopefully, you already are making plans
to attend this important, once-in-a-century meeting. BSA has selected the
design for its Centennial Medallion, and the Centennial Planning Committee
(CPC) thought you might enjoy seeing it.
The plan is for each registrant at the 2006 meeting to receive a medallion.
Also, a limited number of additional medallions will be made, and they
can be ordered for a yet-to-be-determined price. The medallion will be
a reminder of an important milestone in the history of BSA, but if you receive
yours at the Centennial Meeting it will be extra special.
A published history dealing with the one-hundred years of the society
will be available also. This history is being written by Betty Smocovitis
who is using BSA archival materials, once stored at the University of Texas
at Austin Library, and now at the Missouri Botanical Gardens. She is also
utilizing materials provided by a number of society members.
The Centennial Meeting program is being jointly developed by the CPC,
the Program Director, and the Business Office staff. As in past meetings,
the program will include the array of six major symposia, contributed paper
and poster sessions, associated society gatherings and dinners, special events,
and concluding with the annual BSA banquet. The CPC will be inviting representatives
from other affiliated and plant-science societies to join in the celebration.
It is hoped that all active and retired members of the society will want
to join this historic event. More details will come in future PSB issues.
Sincerely, Centennial Planning Committee
Letters
Marsh Sundberg's assessment of the content of botany and biology courses is
very timely as the botanists in the Department of Biological Sciences of the
UW Colleges (Wisconsin's 13 freshman/sophomore liberal arts transfer campuses)
are engaged in re-examining our curriculum. Our work is motivated at least in
part by the unrelenting attack on evolutionary theory by Creationists, Intelligent
Designers, and even the President of the United States. (One has to wonder how
the folks at Yale feel about the latter!)
Sundberg's efforts will be useful to us, but the BSA membership needs
to pick up where he leaves off. Indeed, Marsh calls for just such action
at the end of his article.
I continually wonder where students will learn about the organisms of
the natural world if not in our introductory courses. Contemporary students
by and large are much less likely to have grown up turning over rocks and
building forts in the woods than those of us who have been teaching for
20-30 years. Students know less from the simple childhood observations
than we did.
I compare my 1966 freshman botany book (Wilson and Loomis, Botany
) with Raven, Evert and Eichhorn's Biology of Plants and marvel how
our knowledge has exploded. My freshman semester was 16 weeks long; each
class and lab was filled with work to do. So how do we include not only
classical botany, but in-depth treatment of evolution and biotechnology
as well, without rushing through with such swiftness that it is nothing
more than a cursory glance?
Marsh alludes to the big issue, but it is lost in his final sentence
about content. We need to focus not so much on the content, but the
manner in which we teach our courses. There are many faculty who are providing
students with a much different learning experience than that which Marsh
and I experienced, even if the "content" is the same. A sharing of and
focus on pedagogy that works, as shown by empirical assessment measures,
will be at least as informative as thinking about what topics are covered
in any course.
James W. Perry
Campus Dean
Professor of Biology
University of Wisconsin-Fox Valley
Announcements
Personalia
Karla Meza Awarded Timothy Plowman Scholarship
The Botany Department at the Field Museum recently (June-August 2005)
hosted this year's Timothy Plowman Scholarship Award recipient, Karla
Meza, from the Universidad Nacional de la Amazonía Peruana,
Iquitos, Peru. Karla studies the Heliconiaceae (or Banana Family) and used
her time to examine the extensive herbarium material from the neotropics
housed at F. In addition to basic measurements and observations, she made
numerous determinations of our unidentified collections and added our holdings
in to her database. These data will eventually be part of a monographic
style treatment of the genus Heliconia for the Peruvian Amazon.
Symposia, Conferences, Meetings
2nd Meeting of the International Society for Phylogenetic
Nomenclature
Yale University, New Haven
June 29 _ July 2, 2006
We are pleased to announce the 2nd Meeting of the International Society
for Phylogenetic Nomenclature (ISPN).
Venue:
The meeting and associated social gatherings will be held on Yale University's
beautiful campus in New Haven, Connecticut, USA. Accommodations are being
organized both on and off campus.
Scope:
This meeting will follow the format of the 1st and founding meeting of the
ISPN that was held in Paris, France in 2004 by providing opportunities for
formal oral and poster presentations while leaving ample time for discussions.
The annual business meeting of the ISPN will also be held during this conference.
Conference Language: English
Organizing Committee:
Nico Cellinese, Co-Chair, Yale University
Walter Joyce, Co-Chair, Program Officer, Yale University
Michael Donoghue, Co-Host, Yale University
Jacques Gauthier, Co-Host, Yale University
David Baum, University of Wisconsin
Philip Cantino, Ohio University
Michel Laurin, CNRS, Paris
Kevin de Queiroz, Smithsonian Institution
Registration:
Instructions on how to register will be provided in the second circular.
Important Dates and Deadlines:
Abstract submission deadline: April 1, 2006
Advance registration: May 1, 2006
Contact
Nico Cellinese (Logistics and general information)
Walter Joyce (Program)
Yale Peabody Museum
170 Whitney Avenue
POB 208118
New Haven, Connecticut, 06511 USA
Email: nico.cellinese@yale.edu
or walter.joyce@yale.edu
Award Opportunities
Timothy C. Plowman Latin American Research Award
The Botany Department at The Field Museum invites applications for the
year 2006 Timothy C. Plowman Latin American Research Award
. The award of $2,000.00 is designed to assist students and young professionals
to visit the Field Museum and use our extensive economic botany and systematic
collections. Individuals from Latin America and projects in the field of
ethnobotany or systematics of economically important plant groups will be
given priority consideration. Applicants interested in the award
should submit their curriculum vitae and a detailed letter describing the
project for which the award is sought. The information should be forwarded
to the Timothy C. Plowman Award Committee, Department of Botany, The Field
Museum, 1400 South Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, IL 60605-2496 USA and received
no later than 15 December 2005. Announcement of the recipient will be made
no later than 31 December 2005.
Anyone wishing to contribute to The Timothy C. Plowman Latin American
Research Fund, which supports this award, may send their checks,
payable to The Field Museum, c/o Department of Botany, The Field Museum,
1400 South Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, IL 60605-2496 USA. Make certain to
indicate the intended fund.
Premio de investigación Latinoamericano Timothy C. Plowman
El departamento de Botánica en "The Field Museum" invita aplicaciones
para el premio de investigación Latinoamericano Timothy C. Plowman
2006. Este premio de $2,000.00 fue diseñado para apoyar a estudiantes
y profesionales jóvenes en visitas al museo de Field y utilizar sus extensas
colecciones de botánica económica y sistemática. Se les
dará consideración especial a individuos de Latinoamérica
y a proyectos en los campos de etnobotánica ó sistemática
de plantas económicamente importantes.
Las personas interesadas en aplicar a este premio deberán proveer
su curriculum vitae y una carta detallando el proyecto para el cual el premio
se utilizará. Esta información debe ser enviada al Timothy
C. Plowman Award Committee, Department of Botany, The Field Museum, 1400
South Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, IL 60605-2496 USA y ser recibida antes
del 15 de Diciembre de 2005. El ganador del premio será anunciado
antes del 31 de Diciembre de 2005.
Cualquier persona que desee contribuir al Fondo de investigación
latinoamericano Timothy C. Plowman, el cual apoya este premio, puede
enviar su cheque, pagadero a "The Field Museum, c/o Department of Botany,
The Field Museum, 1400 South Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, IL 60605-2496 USA".
Asegúrese de indicar el fondo al cual se destina su contribución.
NATIONAL TROPICAL BOTANICAL GARDEN FELLOWSHIP for
COLLEGE PROFESSORS
Program Operation: June 12-23, 2006
Deadline to Apply: March 24, 2006
Notification of Acceptance:March 31, 2006
COURSE DESCRIPTION
The National Tropical Botanical Garden (NTBG) will host another exciting Fellowship
for College Professors of introductory biology from June 12-23, 2006 at The
Kampong, Coconut Grove, Florida. College professors accepted to the Fellowship
will become Fellows at the National Tropical Botanical Garden.
The goal of the NTBG Fellowship is to improve the quality of teaching
in introductory biology classes at the undergraduate level. Facilitated
by Professor P. Barry Tomlinson of Harvard University and Dr. Paul Alan
Cox, CEO/Director of the Institute for Ethnomedicine, the course is designed
to show instructors how to use examples from tropical plants in discussing
issues of form and function, evolution, and conservation. Fellows will
develop teaching modules to be shared and implemented in the introductory
biology classroom. Basically, we are looking for the very best biology faculty,
those who can fire the imagination of major and non-major biology students.
Although botanists will be considered, we also welcome applications from
faculty who lack previous botanical experiences as well as those who have
not previously worked in the tropics. The Fellowship will be limited to
12 Fellows.
Applications must include:
· Two letters
of recommendation
· Complete Curriculum Vitae
· Copy of the most recent teacher evaluation
· A non-refundable
$USD30 application fee in the form of a check or money order
made payable to the National Tropical Botanical Garden.
The Fellowship will cover the most economical roundtrip airfare to The
Kampong, Florida, accommodation and meals, tuition and fees, texts, equipment,
and ground transportation
Requests about the NTBG Fellowship must be directed to:
Director of Education
National Tropical Botanical Garden
3530 Papalina Road
Kalaheo, HI 96741
Tel: (808) 332-7324 ext. 225 or 251
Fax: (808) 332-9765
Email: education@ntbg.org
Website: www.ntbg.org
Courses/Workshops
Biology S-105 "Biodiversity of tropical plants."
The National Tropical Botanical Garden in collaboration with the Harvard
Summer School and Fairchild Tropical Botanic Garden
Instructor: P. Barry Tomlinson, Professor of Biology Emeritus
, Harvard University and Crum Professor of Tropical Botany, National Tropical
Botanical Garden.
Time: June 26 - July 21, 2006.
Location:
The Kampong, National Tropical Botanical Garden, 4013 Douglas Road, Coconut
Grove, Miami, Florida 33133
At the Kampong the class will use the living accommodation provided in
an air-conditioned dormitory-type facility (Scarborough House) and the
newly -constructed teaching laboratory. This is supplemented by the teaching
facility at the Center for Plant Conservation of Fairchild Garden.
Prerequisites:
Preferred Introductory Botany at the undergraduate college level.
Selection:
To be based on the prior experience of the student and the suitability of
the course for graduate advancement. As in previous years the course will
cater for students with broad interests who seek to become more familiar
with tropical plants.
Course description:
The course is directed toward students already enrolled or about to be enrolled
in a graduate program and will introduce the diversity of tropical plant
types within a biological and systematic framework. Study will be based
on the living collections of the Kampong, supplemented by those at other
South Florida institutions (e.g., Fairchild Tropical Botanical Garden and
the Montgomery Botanical Center, Coral Gables, FL) and on plants in natural
environments (e.g., Biscayne Bay and the Everglades National park). This
is a teaching resource of some 10,000 species representing all tropical
groups.
The work involves classroom and laboratory demonstration combined with
outdoor presentations and excursions. The final week of the course requires
each student to prepare an individual research project leading to a written
and graded report.
The course is designed to develop a comparative approach to the study
of plants that will broaden general understanding of their structure and
function.
Enrollment: Limited to 12
Credits: 4
Estimated tuition: ~$2,300
Application: Students will be regularly enrolled in the 2006 Harvard
summer School program, Selection is based on a Supplementary Application
Form. Application materials will be available at
www.summer.harvard.edu
in early 2006.
Further information and enquiries from Professor Tomlinson (
pbtomlin@fas.harvard.edu
).
Positions Available
Paleobotanist.
East Tennessee State University
The Department of Biological Sciences at East Tennessee State University
invites applications for an Assistant Professor tenure-track position beginning
August, 2006. The successful candidate will participate in research at
an outstanding local Late Miocene fossil site. Responsibilities include
classroom and lab instruction and mentoring student research at undergraduate
and graduate levels. Ph.D. required at hire date.
The Department of Biological Sciences is currently comprised of fourteen
faculty members engaged in a wide range of research programs and serves
approximately 250 majors and 20 M.S. students. Further information concerning
the department is available at www.etsu.edu/biology.
The Don Sundquist Center for Excellence in Paleontology is under development
in Gray, Tennessee, 15 miles from the main ETSU campus. A museum with
research facilities and visitor center is planned for this unique Late Miocene
forested site. Additional information about the Gray site is available
at http://www.etsu.edu/grayfossilsite/
.
East Tennessee State University is located in Johnson City, Tennessee,
a city of about 55,000 located in the southern Appalachian Mountains.
The region has a total population of more than 400,000 and combines a low
cost of living with amenities found in larger urban areas. ETSU enrolls
approximately 12,000 students and offers more than thirty master's degree
programs and six doctoral degree programs. Submit c.v., transcripts, statements
of research and teaching interests, and three letters of reference electronically
to paleobotanist@etsu.edu
. Application review will begin on 12/1/05. ETSU is an AA/EO employer.
Systematic and Evolutionary Biology
University of Georgia
The Plant Biology Department at the University of Georgia has an opening
for an Assistant or Associate Professor in Systematic and Evolutionary Biology.
We seek a systematic biologist who uses innovative approaches to address
fundamental questions about plants, algae or fungi in areas such as phylogenetics,
molecular evolution, speciation or genome evolution. The successful candidate
is expected to develop a vigorous, externally-funded research program and
to teach and train undergraduate and graduate students in systematics.
Cover letter, curriculum vitae, short statements of research interests
and teaching philosophy and no more than five reprints should be assembled
into a single pdf file and submitted online at
http://www.plantbio.uga.edu/positions.html
. Candidates should request four referees to submit letters of recommendation
to the same site or by mail to Systematic and Evolutionary Biology Search
Committee, Plant Biology Department, University of Georgia, Athens, GA USA
30602-7271. Applications received by November 4, 2005 are assured full consideration.
The Franklin College of Arts and Sciences is committed to increasing the
diversity of its faculty and strongly encourages applications from individuals
in under-represented groups. UGA is an Equal Opportunity Employer.
Orchid Taxonomist
Marie Selby Botanical Gardens
Job Title: Curator, Orchid Identification Center (OIC)
Reports To: Head of Systematics
Position: 40 hours. Includes benefits.
Start Date: As soon as possible
The Selby Botanical Gardens Research & Conservation Department seeks
an experienced orchid taxonomist to manage its Orchid Identification Center
(OIC). The curator must be able to aid department taxonomists in the accurate
identification of Orchidaceae to species level, be familiar with relevant
botanical literature, and be able to supervise volunteers, students, and
interns. The successful candidate will manage and update the OIC species
files and the Spirit Collection of 24,000 specimens, as well as write articles
and provide lectures for public and scientific audiences, seek funding opportunities,
and be willing to participate in international fieldwork.
Minimum education/experience: M.Sc. in orchid taxonomy preferred or B.Sc.
in botany with two years practical experience in orchid identification.
Experience in a herbarium or museum environment a plus. Excellent communication
and computer skills (i.e., Microsoft Word, Outlook, Excel, Access, Adobe
PhotoShop) required. Selby Gardens is an equal opportunity employer and
a drug free workplace.
Applications will be accepted until the position is filled. Please send C.V.
and the names of three references to:
Wesley E. Higgins, Ph.D.
Head of Systematics
The Marie Selby Botanical Gardens
811 South Palm Avenue
Sarasota, Florida 34236 U.S.A.
Office: (941) 955-7553 ext. 315
Fax: (941) 951-1474
E-mail: whiggins@selby.org
Website: www.selby.org
|